Shockers at the Indie Spirits

Two curious creatures emerged from the sea of Independent Spirit nominations: "The Squid and the Whale."
The critically hailed feature was expected to surface in some top categories, but it darn near drowned the competition, reaping 6 noms. Such generous recognition is rich reward for a little indie that was shot in 23 days for only $1.5 million, then taken to the Sundance Film Festival where it enjoyed the ultimate Cinderella experience. Two hefty players picked up distribution rights: Samuel Goldwyn Films and Sony Pictures Entertainment.
But something's fishy.
Photo: "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada" got buried by the indie competition despite having a notable "For Your Consideration" ad campaign.
(Sony Pictures Classics)
Looks like somebody pulled a hustle on "Hustle & Flow." That masterpiece deserves major mention because it only got made after filmmakers took out extra mortgages on their homes. Aren't those the kinds of films that the Indie Spirits are all about? The kudos are supposed to trumpet the underdog films, not big-buck spectacles like "Brokeback Mountain," which competes for best picture at the Spirits and will probably do so at the Oscars, too.
At least star Terrence Howard got nommed for best actor. That's more than can be said for snubee Tommy Lee Jones, who stars, and makes his directorial debut, in ' "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada." The film has key critical support, plus it won best actor and screenplay honors at Cannes in May. Some award watchers believe "Three Burials" has such strong buzz now that it could turn out to be a major player at the Oscars where actors comprise the largest voting bloc and often root for fellow actors, even when they compete out of category.
But not only did Spirit voters fail to give Jones bids for either best director or actor, the latter snub really hurts because costar Barry Pepper made the cut for best supporting actor with a far less emotive role.
Where's Cillian Murphy? Perhaps he's really having breakfast on Pluto. If so, he's no doubt breaking bagels with Joan Allen, who's got good reason to be ticked off about the oversight of "The Upside of Anger."
Many Spirit gurus believed that this year's noms would be dominated by "Hustle," "Three Burials," "Upside" and "Pluto" in addition to some films that did fare fairly well: "Capote," "Crash," "Transamerica" and "Good Night, and Good Luck."
Next: Will there be huge jaw-droppers on awards night in March?



I just saw The Three Burials, here in Paris, where it opened last week. The surprise for me was that Barry Pepper is the stand-out, in a very physicaly and emotionallly demanding role, not Tommy Lee Jones, despite the hype and the Cannes award. Jones is wonderful in a simmering, low-key way, but I don't really think his performance is Oscar caliber, so I'm not shocked at all about his "snub". Pepper's supporting role and the screenplay are the real serious contenders. Plus, the movie's too morbid to be the kind of thing that Academy voters tend to go for.
Posted by: B Signor | December 01, 2005 at 12:53 AM