Can Abigail be nominated for best actress?
It's a longshot, sure, but let's have some fun with a zany kid and a crazy idea. Let's explore a real Oscar possibility that was introduced by the shocking nomination of "Whale Rider" star Keisha Castle-Hughes in the best-actress race of 2002. Can the same thing happen next to another adorable young gal — the unflaggingly sunny little one who truly shines in "Little Miss Sunshine"?
Abigail Breslin has such a winning personality that her screen family will go to extraordinary lengths — in a busted VW van that can't stop rolling, no less — to get her to a talent contest in far-off California. Moviegoers have been so won over by her that, nearly three months after its release, the film still shines in more than 800 theaters and, as of this week, earned the exact sum ($55 million) as an Oscar rival that kept on rolling at theaters last year: "Crash."
Surely, "Sunshine" will be nommed for best comedy/musical picture at the Golden Globes and it could make the top five at Oscars, too. Breslin is a strong contender for supporting actress. Toni Collette, as her mom, probably matches her in screen time, but a good case can be made for Abigail as female lead. After all, she's the title character — just like Meryl Streep in "The Devil Wears Prada" and Forest Whitaker in "Last King of Scotland," who are supporting stars campaigning for lead this year.
Currently, Abigail is angling for supporting, but Oscar voters can put an actor wherever they please, as a startled Keisha Castle-Hughes discovered three years ago. Keisha was her film's title character, too, and campaigned in supporting because that's where Oscar voters put all kids, like it or not. Even when they're the obvious lead star like Tatum O'Neal was in "Paper Moon," who ended up winning best supporting actress at age 10.
At age 13, Keisha set a new record for youngest gal ever nommed for best actress, an achievement that could be eclipsed this year by 10-year-old Abigail. Both gals' roles are equally charming and have gung-ho spunk. There are two key differences, however. "Whale Rider" had a serious political/social theme as Keisha struggled for female empowerment in a male-dominated New Zealand culture. Abigail's role doesn't have that political weight or emotional oomph — or screen time. Will those issues matter? Sometimes just charm is enough — think sweet and frothy Juliette Binoche in "Chocolat."
Photo: If Abigail Breslin wins in the supporting race, Tatum O'Neal will remain the youngest champ, but Abigail could set a new record in the lead actress matchup.
(Fox Searchlight)




I'd be afraid if she campaigned for lead. I mean, that race is so packed as it is right now: Mirren, Winslet, Cruz, possibly Miller, and then either Dench or Blanchett or both over Miller--it's too much! Her decision to run for supporting is very smart, especially since the movie gives the most screentime to her character's parents, Collette and Kinnear. I think if she was in supporting, I could see her and Arkin nabbing noms easily, especially with this DVD-push. Besides, don't forget, Vanessa Redgrave was the lead character in Julia, just to name one example, and she fared well remaining in the proper category.
As far as child performances go though, don't forget about the outstanding Shareeka Epps, who proved to be a wonderful match for Ryan Gosling's stellar acting in Half Nelson.
FYI: Owen Gleiberman (of Entertainment Weekly) is a douchebag who's lost all credibility after giving The Black Dahlia a B- and Little Miss Sunshine a C-.
Posted by: James D. | October 16, 2006 at 09:13 AM
WHat about Keke Palmer? If any child actor carried a film this year, its her.
Posted by: JPatterson | October 12, 2006 at 04:05 PM
Wait...you say that she's aiming for supporting but in the Golden Globe line-up she's in lead. Which is wihc?
Posted by: Mike B. | October 11, 2006 at 04:14 PM
Thanks for putting Abigail Breslin in the spotlight Tom - So far this year, no other performance has really affected me as much as hers - a wonderful showcase from a talented kid - she deserves a nod this year, and I truly hope she gets it - lead or supporting - I really don't mind either way.
Good work mate.
Posted by: Robert Licuria | October 11, 2006 at 04:00 PM
Although Abigail is the title character, I would think that she would be in supporting because unlike Streep, Whitaker and even Keisha Castle-Hughes, she doesn't get top billing for the movie. I think Keisha really was the lead in Whale Rider where others, like Haley Joel Osment were second on the billing to the big star (in that case Bruce Willis). I think that Abigail and Steve Carell are good choices to get into the supporting race... I honestly know only one person on the face of the planet who hated that movie.
Posted by: EDouglas | October 11, 2006 at 01:30 PM