Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

How many Oscar nominations will 'Dreamgirls' get?

November 17, 2006 | 10:53 am

Dreamgirlsbeyonce

If you believe, like many Oscar gurus, that "Dreamgirls" is the best-picture frontrunner, then you must think that it'll nab the most nominations, since that parallel usually follows. Over the past 20 years, the movie with the most bids has won best picture 17 times. The exceptions: In 1991, "The Silence of the Lambs" (7 noms) beat "Bugsy" (10), "JFK" (8) and "The Prince of Tides" (7). In 2001, "A Beautiful Mind" (8) beat "Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" (13). At the 2005 derby, "Crash" (6) upset "Brokeback Mountain" (8).

So . . . how many noms can "Dreamgirls" score? Pete Hammond at HollywoodWiretap.com believes Danny Glover could be nommed for supporting actor, in addition to Eddie Murphy. That's interesting. I don't agree, but let's count Glover for the heck of it along with likely noms for picture, director, screenplay, supporting actress (Jennifer Hudson), supporting actor (Murphy), art direction, cinematography, costumes, editing and sound.

That adds up to 11 noms so far. Then you must consider the song race where "Dreamgirls" will nab at least one bid for one of the four new tunes added to the original Broadway score. "Listen" is probably strongest, but "I Love You, I Do" could be nommed, too. If so, that brings us up to 13 noms, curiously the same total that another musical scripted by Bill Condon, "Chicago," had prior to winning best pic.

Personally, I think "Dreamgirls" will nab 11, including the two song bids. Sorry, Danny, you're really good in "Dreamgirls," but supporting actor is a crowded race.

How many nominations do you think "Dreamgirls" will nab? Please click the "Comments" link below and pipe in!

Photo: There's a remote possibility that Beyonce Knowles could be nominated for best supporting actress if Jennifer Hudson gets pushed up to lead by the Golden Globes, SAG awards or film-critics' kudos, then the Oscars. If that happened, Beyonce would be wise to just step aside and let the diva have her day, and drop down to the supporting race. Frankly, Beyonce's performance isn't strong enough to nab an Oscar nom in lead. She might have a shot in supporting, but that's all at the Oscars. Things may be different at the Golden Globes where Beyonce has an excellent shot at being nominated in the lead race. But that will be in the separate category for musical/comedy actresses, which is distinct from the drama race. At the Oscars there are only 5 slots for best actress, not 10. Five of them have to be ditched by the time you move on to the Oscars. Beyonce's will be one of the first to go. Her only hope of being among the nominees personally is to step down to supporting. It's a longshot, but her only shot.
(DreamWorks/Paramount)

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments

Tom,
I predict 10 nominations:

Picture
Director
Supporting Actor Murphy
Supporting Actress. Hudson
Screenplay
Editing
Art Direction
Costumes
Cinematography
Song "Listen"

I haven't seen this film yet but Best Pic seems like a stretch to me. I think Eddie Murphy may get recognized. I guess all the AI lovers think Jennifer Hudson but I can't see why, I mean she can sing but who says she can act? I think costuming, art direction and original song. Maybe editing. So I'm gonna go with 5.

7 nominations is my bet:
picture
director
jennifer hudson
costumes
art direction
1 original song, not both
editing

The writers are usually (not always, but usually) the most learned members of the academy as far as to what is actually good work. Granted I haven't seen DREAMGIRLS...but there seems to be a butt load of remarkable screen writing this year...it may have to fight for that adapted screenplay nod.

Read it again, Kamilla. Tx for pointing out that caption -- I didn't realize I'd left out some info. So I've rewritten it. TX

I'm betting a good 12: Picture, Director, Supporting Actor (Murphey), Supporting Actress (Hudson), Screenplay, Editing, Art Direction, Costumes, Sound Mixing, Cinematography, Song "Listen", and another Song "Love You I Do."

Wow...12, that's fantastic.

Tom, I didn't understand one thing about your text: If Jennifer receives Best Actress nominations at the Globes and SAGs, will she campaign for a lead actress nomination and Beyonce for a best actress nomination???

For now, I am predicting it: Supporting Actor (Eddie Murphy), Supporting Actress (Jennifer Hudson), Art Direction, Cinematography, Costume Design, Director (Bill Condon), Editing, Original Score, Original Song ("Listen" and "Love You I Do"), Picture, Sound and Adapted Screenplay.

So, that makes 13 nominations for "Dreamgirls".

I'm going with 11: Picture, Director, S.Actor, S.Actress, Song, Cinematography, Editing, Sound, Costumes, Art Direction, A.Screenplay. You're right, these are the most likely. If the picture receives wide critical acclaim and B.O. numbers are outta control, then the Beyonce might get pulled into the mix. If Dreamgirls is as big as we all think it will be, the Academy might be extra generous. Whatever the case, I just want Condon recognized for his genius.

I predict at least 12 noms. Pic, Director, Supporting Actor, Supporting Actress, Song, Score, Sound, Editing, Costume, Cinematography, Sound Editing, Art Direction and maybe Screenplay Adaptation but this would probably be its weakest entry.

I'm thinking anywhere between 10 and 13. Right now I'm going with 12. By the way, you forgot that Million Dollar Baby beat The Aviator in best picture, and that Million Dollar Baby had 4 fewer noms.



Stay Connected:


Advertisement

About the Blogger


The Dish Rag
Pop & Hiss
Notes on a Season
The Circuit: Awards and Festivals News



Categories


Archives