Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Indie Spirits bask in 'Sunshine,' but snub Abby!

November 28, 2006 | 12:38 pm

Poor Abigail Breslin must feel a lot less sunny than usual today.

While "Little Miss Sunshine" and "Half Nelson" emerged as the big champs at the Indie Spirit noms with 5 bids each, the "Little Miss" star was missing from the kudos spotlight. What made it odd — and, let's be honest, a gyp! — was that the young gal starring in "Nelson" — Shareeka Epps not only got a bid, but in the lead actress race despite expectations that she might, if nommed, land in supporting. Granted, Shareeka is aces on screen and deserves award recognition, but she doesn't cast the same blinding light Abby does.

Sunshinenelson

Does this mean that Shareeka may turn out to be the Adorable Young Gal of 2006 (this year's Tatum O'Neal or Anna Paquin) who gets nommed at the Oscars, not Abby? Or is it just a case of Abby being too cutesy, too sugary, not gritty in the way edgy indie filmakers usually like? It's one thing for them to acknowledge the amazing success of "Sunshine" — they really had to, considering it's the breakout indie hit of the year — but hugging Abby may strike them as utterly uncool. If that's the reason for her snub, then she'll likely re-emerge as a contender at the Globes (where she's eligible in the lead comedy actress race) and Oscars (where she's campaigning in the supporting category). However, if this snub is evidence of filmmakers not taking Abby seriously as an actress, then this could spell doom for her at kudos ahead. Today Abby's costar Alan Arkin nabbed a Spirit bid, making it look more likely that he'll be noticed by the foreign press and film academy.

But the biggest winnah of all was really Ryan Gosling, who is now, officially, the darling of the indie set. Considering that he's long been favored to win one of the best-actor kudos from the New York Film Critics Circle or Los Angeles Film Critics' Association next when they vote in early December, it's looking more and more likely that he'll land on the Oscar list next.

Others who got a notable Oscar boost from today's noms, too: "For Your Consideration's" Catherine O'Hara (nommed for lead actress instead of supporting), the new James Bond star Daniel Craig as Truman Capote's kisser in "Infamous," "Thank You For Smoking" star Aaron Eckhart and scripter Jason Reitman, "The Painted Veil" star Edward Norton and scriptwriter Ron Nyswaner — plus "Pan's Labyrinth" and "The Dead Girl."

The inclusion of Spanish-language "Pan's" seems surprising, but let's recall that "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" won best pic, director (Ang Lee) and supporting actress (Ziyi Zhang) in 2000. "Pan's" qualifies because most of its financing came from Yankee sources and because director/writer Guillermo del Toro lives in the U.S. However, it still looks like an oddball choice considering it's Mexico's entry in Oscar's foreign-film race, but not put in the equivalent lineup at the Spirits.

Pans

Meantime, "The Queen," "Venus," "Last King of Scotland," "The History Boys" and "Borat" didn't qualify because their filmmakers or production companies are based in Britain. The Spirits have a separate category for foreign films, but they didn't pop up there. Other movies like "Little Children" and "Bobby" didn't qualify because they didn't fit all four criteria cited by Film Independent, which bestows the prizes: 1. Uniqueness of vision; 2. Original, provocative subject matter; 3. Economy of means (with particular attention paid to total production cost and individual compensation); 4. Percentage of financing from independent sources. Nominees were determined by a panels of 15 filmakers (directors, writers, actors) and journalists. Also, films must be made for less than $20 million; 250 qualified for entry.

Last year the Spirits and Oscars shared three of the same nominees for best pic: "Capote," "Brokeback Mountain" and "Good Night, and Good Luck." "Brokeback" won best picture, "Crash" won the separate race for best first feature and "Capote" star Philip Seymour Hoffman won best actor. Very often the Spirits indicate who the strongest Oscar contenders are among the indie set, as "Sideways," "Monster" and "Lost in Translation" also recently demonstrated.

Strangely missing from today's nominees were candidates whose films showed strong support in other categories: Naomi Watts ("The Painted Veil") and Robert Downey Jr. ("A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints").

Top photos: "Little Miss Sunshine" took five Spirit noms, but none for its sunny little star — 10-year-old Abigail Breslin. "Half Nelson" star Shareeka Epps (here with costar Ryan Gosling) earned the Aw-Ain't-She-Cute Vote instead. Shareeka was only in her mid-teens when she appeared in "Half Nelson" (and appeared to be younger), but now she's a senior in high school (about 17 years old — no official age is listed at IMDB.com). Bottom photos: "Pan's Labyrinth's" nom for best picture was a huge Spirit shockeroo.
(Fox Searchlight/ Think Films/ Picturehouse)

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments

One more thing. I don't find it odd at all that Shareeka Epps was nominated in the lead category. Shareeka IS one of the leads. With no formal training, she matches and holds her own with powerhouse Ryan Gosling. I was resigned to rooting for her in the supporting actress category since, as a newcomer, she was more likely to be placed in that category.

Tom, I'm going to assume you've seen Half Nelson because otherwise your comments comparing Shareeka Epps and Abigal Breslin are irresponsible. I think you're wrong, I agree with cc and Felix, but I hope you've seen Half Nelson.

LMS had the advantage of its well-known, stellar cast and being a quirky, offbeat comedy. Abigail was sparkling and energetic. What's not to love? Aside from the disadvantage of not having Fox Searchlight's publicity/promotion budget (if it had, would Half Nelson have been the indie hit of the year?), Half Nelson was a downer of a drama (albeit with comic moments) and serious -- definitely not a feelgood movie, even if I left the theater with a full heart and soul. Definitely the underdog. Abigail may have blinded you with her light, but Shareeka burned with a quiet fire -- on the treasured, rare occasions when she smiled, it was like the sun rising and spreading over the land from horizon to horizon.

Funny, everything I read and heard since Sundance made Little Miss Sunshine, Abigail, and her co-stars as runaway favorites with clear sailing through the whole awards season. It seemed Abigail's warm and sunny persona was invincible.

And I wouldn't knock Anna Paquin's and Tatum O'Neal's performances, if I were you. If so, it'd only be fair to knock Abby's performance for being cute and young.

Go Marcia-Marcia GH has to win supporting actress.

Tom, do you seriously think Breslin is better or more deserving than Epps? And this 'blinding light' you speak of was pretty nonexistent in the performance I saw Breslin give.. was she good? sure, but hardly the deserving actor you make her out to be. And anyone who sees 'Half Nelson' knows that Epps was beyond brilliant in her role and it's reassuring to know the Spirit nominating committee agree.

I agree with cc, I mean.. you have seen 'Half Nelson', right?

Sorry, Gothams, THIS is a worthy list of indie nominees!

I'm particularly jazzed about 3 films that I've had the pleasure of seeing thrill audiences on a grassroots level: FOUR EYED MONSTERS (with no distributor, it's about to have a week's engagement in NYC after popular limited demand)....WRISTCUTTERS: A LOVE STORY, which continually wins audience awards at film festivals like the one I worked last spring (Gen Art's in NY)....and speaking of audience awards, the co-winner of that prize at Hamptons Intl. Film Festival a year ago, and now in a slow national release, the extremely worthy SWEET LAND.

When watching this film in NY this past month to nearly empty theaters, after 93% positive reviews so far (check Rottentomatoes.com), I felt that it so deserves nominations in the Oscars, the Globes....and the Spirits, that I was so happy this morning when they announced SWEET LAND as a nominee for Best First Film, and the luminous Elizabeth Reaser for Best Actress. It's in LA and Chicago now, and will return to NY soon, but other cities await.

I don't work for the film....I just know in my gut this film could be the dark horse in all the awards and year-end critics lists. It's that special.

If only the public knew about it. Now...there's a chance they will, if this starts the ball rolling..........

How does Jason Reitman not get nominated for best first film. Thank You for Somking should have been nomminated for best picture too. I mean freaking Ameircan Gun had 37% on rotten tomatoes.

"Shareeka Epps earned the Aw-Ain't-She-Cute Vote instead."

Before anyone makes any sort of opinionated statements on Half-Nelson and Epps, maybe they should... oh, I don't know... see the movie first? Whatever else Shareeka Epps performance was - and I thought she was terrific - she was NOT CUTE. She didn't play her role cute, the role isn't written cute, and the movie never exploits her age in order to bring across some cheap sentiment. There isn't a single cute scene or moment in the entire movie, despite a cast that includes a classroom of kids. And no one who saw the film could think otherwise.

Could we be any more disingenuous? I don't think so.



Stay Connected:


Advertisement

About the Blogger


The Dish Rag
Pop & Hiss
Notes on a Season
The Circuit: Awards and Festivals News



Categories


Archives