PGA nominees: Did 'Iwo Jima' commit kudos hari-kari?
The omission of "Letters from Iwo Jima" from the list of best pic nominees from the Producers Guild of America shocked the Drudge Report, which reported in its headline: "Praised Eastwood flick overlooked in key Oscars indicator."
But Mr. Drudge shouldn't have been surprised. As I've reported a lot recently: late-December releases have been punished in the derby ever since the introduction of the new Oscar calendar several years ago. It's time studios started to pay attention. When PGA voters got their nomination ballots in early December, they didn't yet have DVD screeners of Eastwood's offbeat Japanese-language contender to watch. Most kudos voters check off ballots within the first few weeks, award accountants say. Eastwood's late-December release two years ago, "Million Dollar Baby," was different. Voters knew it was loaded up with superstars giving socko perfs — so they eagerly watched the film. Far fewer guild voters will rush to see a subtitled film about a war we won 60 years ago, but now paints us as the bad guys.
Last year some film critics had misgivings about "Munich," sure, but it got nommed for best pic at the Oscars. However, it was snubbed by PGA voters, many of whom probably didn't see it because it debuted in theaters at Christmastime and was about a subject that made them queasy — it portrayed the Olympics terrorists somewhat sympathetically. A movie like that and "Iwo Jima" need to be out earlier in order to give hesitant voters a chance to warm up to them. Last year PGA voters opted for "Walk the Line" instead, a fall release that was already a big breakout success financially — an issue that producers care lots about, of course.
The PGA has predicted Oscar best-picture champs 11 times over 17 years. Last year the guild opted for "Brokeback Mountain," the academy for "Crash." There'd probably be more overlap if the calendar wasn't an issue. Two years ago PGA picked "Aviator" like the Golden Globes did while the juggernaut behind "Million Dollar Baby" was still cranking up.
Usually, guild and Oscar nominees are off by one or two entries. Two years ago PGA chose "The Incredibles" over "Ray," which had late-breaking momentum thanks to a blitz of "For Your Consideration" ads in the L.A. Times, Variety and the Hollywood Reporter. In 2003, PGA cited six nominees, but none were Oscar contender "Lost in Translation" — the other two were "Cold Mountain" (a much better choice, in my stubborn opinion) and "The Last Samurai" (no comment). The two groups had exact matches in 1991 and 1992.
This year the nominees are: "Babel," "The Departed," "Dreamgirls," "Little Miss Sunshine" and "The Queen." I have a hunch the nominees will line up with Oscars this year.




Let's face it, "Letters From Iwo Jima"should probably be called "Springtime For Tojo".
There is no great love out there for a movie that makes the barbaric Imperial Army of Japan look sympathetic despite the public's distaste for the Iraq War.
This look at the war from the view of enemy soldiers would not be even remotely considered for the European theater of WWII.And rightfully so.
So what is old Clint trying to prove here?
What's next , "Letters From Tora Bora"?
A sympathetic portrayal of Al-Qaeda terrorists at the Tora Bora cave complex.
The poor terrorists sitting there while "dasy cutters" and bunker busters are raining down on them.
Clint could even save money on the sets fro the WWII movie.
Since it primarily was shot in caves.
Posted by: Richie F | January 04, 2007 at 01:53 PM
To try and not think that Little Miss Sunshine might not make the cut is absurd. It's a great movie, and plus Oscar will nominate it because it wants to appear to be indie.
I think the ultimate victor at the Awards will come down to babel, The Departed, and Dreamgirls. The Queen might be the dark horse candidate.
Posted by: Seth | January 04, 2007 at 11:27 AM
The Oscar list for Best Picture will be as follows: BABEL, THE DEPARTED, DREAMGIRLS, LETTERS FROM IWO JIMA, THE QUEEN. LITTLE MISS SUNSHINE--too cute, funny but not Best Picture caliber. BABEL and LETTERS FROM IWO JIMA will probably cancel eachother out--they're critically acclaimed, yes, but too bold for the Academy's taste. THE DEPARTED, DREAMGIRLS, and THE QUEEN are safer bets. THE DEPARTED's chances of winning Best Picture is strong because of the strong cast of Leo, Jack, Matt & Mark and Marty at the helm. It's done box office biz well, critics liked it and commercially easy to market to the movie going public. DREAMGIRLS, mixed reviews but strong cast, good musical picture, well done production overall (i.e. costumes, hair, art direction, cinematography, sound, etc.), doing very well at the box office. It's very commercial and appealing to audiences of all ages. THE QUEEN--strong performances, but stuffy, stodgy British film for the stuffy, stodgy Academy members who love anything British...can become the upset victory a la CRASH. Let's hope not though.
Posted by: Frankie R. | January 04, 2007 at 09:26 AM