Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Will Angela Lansbury become Tony's biggest winner?

June 7, 2007 |  3:26 pm

Actually, two actresses could claim a fifth career Tony this weekend and tie Julie Harris as the biggest winner in the Broadway award's history: Audra McDonald ("110 in the Shade") and Angela Lansbury ("Deuce"). But, let's be honest, Angie has the best shot.

However, can Angie really do it? She's received good reviews in "Deuce," but the play's been slammed by critics. That may not matter, though. It's possible that she's simply unbeatable, even in a lesser play. After all, she's never lost — she's gone four for four at Tonys past.

Lansburypullquote_2But one key thing should be noted here. Angie recently returned to Broadway after 25 years. On one hand that should put some sentiment on her side, that's true, but, on the other, the voting base has changed since she went undefeated in the past. Will new voters still automatically check off their ballots for her?

Personally, I think she'll prevail, but I thought it wise to check the logical thinking of another one of our pundits who's picking Angie, too. I asked Martin Denton of the excellent site NYTheatre.com(NYTheatre.com) (CLICK HERE) to share his thoughts with us.

Here's his full analysis of that best actress race — the words below are Martin's:

I'm thinking the main factor here is timing. After "The Little Dog Laughed" opened, my money would have been on Julie White getting some long-overdue recognition for a performance that everybody loved. But then Vanessa Redgrave opened in her solo show, "The Year of Magical Thinking," and after I saw that I thought, "Sorry Julie — you've been outclassed, big-time." (I would still argue that no performance on Broadway this season, male or female, play or musical, came close to Redgrave's in terms of sheer craft.)

Then Eve Best arrived in "A Moon for the Misbegotten," and she got all the attention for a while. But then came Angela Lansbury, capping the season (and, one assumes, a tremendously distinguished career) in "Deuce," showing everybody how it's done and winning plenty of extravagant praise. She's the one folks will remember when they cast their ballots.

(You'll note I haven't mentioned the fifth nominee, Swoosie Kurtz. But it's the same logic: who remembers "Heartbreak House" at this point?)

I can offer a couple more arguments for Lansbury's victory. I would imagine that Best is her strongest competitor. But history tells us that Josie Hogan, great role though it is, doesn't yield Tonys. Only Colleen Dewhurst won for this role (though all the other Broadway Josies have, I believe, been nominated: Wendy Hiller, Kate Nelligan, and Cherry Jones).

Finally, if the Tony voters are interested in great television (and they should be!), Lansbury is the only choice. All you have to do is sit in the Music Box Theatre to know how beloved a figure she has become for American audiences. She delivers star power AND brilliant acting; most TV stars don't manage that (they play themselves, not characters). If anybody deserves to tie Julie Harris as all-time Tony champ, it's Angela Lansbury. And the crowd at the Tonys and the folks watching them at home will be thrilled to see her win (especially after all those years of not winning an Emmy!)

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments

Making a Tony prediction off the the quality of an actor's work in the past is wrong. Maybe some people should actually see the shows at hand before they make predictions. An actress is not deserving of a Tony if she sits in a chair (as someone offstage feeds her lines) lamenting over her unfulfilled life. And what is worse, is that people agree with what you are saying that Landsbury should win to catch up to Julie Harris - which is dispicable, and frankly insulting to the other actresses in the category who deserve the title of Best Actress.

Eve Best shines in Moon, and she is absolutely deserving of the Tony. I do believe that all of these "pundits" are grossly overlooking Julie White's performance in Little Dog Laughed. Her eccentric character and line delivery kept you at the edge of your seat. When you are watching a performance, and can't turn away, that says something.

All are great actresses, but I don't think Swoosie Kurtz has a shot this year. Julie White was great in The Little Dog Laughed, as was Redgrave in Magical Thinking, although her win a few years back for Long Day's Journey Into Night may keep some from voting for her. Eve Best's reviews were glowing, and was practically the only bright spot in the show's notices (I haven't seen the show). Lansbury's performance in Deuce is remarkable, and if she wins it will be for quality as well as sentimentality. And she has the advantage of being a theatre veteran, not some TV star trying a few months on Broadway to see what it's like. My money is on her, and if she does win, prepare for an ovation that Broadway hasn't seen in quite some time.

i think i might tend to agree although my bet was on eve..but it would also make great tv to see redgrave win..wonder if she will mention the state of the world



Stay Connected:


Advertisement

About the Blogger


The Dish Rag
Pop & Hiss
Notes on a Season
The Circuit: Awards and Festivals News



Categories


Archives