We do know that he's referring specifically to these other episodes: The Office ("The Coup") Scrubs ("My Musical") Thirty Rock ("Hard Ball") Weeds ("Cooking with Jesus"). It's a shockeroo that "My Musical" is going over so poorly with this judge. TV critics gushed over it earlier this year, but it's gimmicky: a patient imagines the hospital staff performing musical song-and-dance numbers. "The Coup" was well received by critics, too — Steve Carell's character Michael imagines that Dwight is scheming to take over his job when Michael gets in trouble for showing movies to the staff.

Yesterday (Saturday) the drama panel powwow lasted more than 10 frustrating hours. Judges chose not to break for lunch, but rather to eat while the viewing marathon continued, often painfully. "I gave my number one vote to 'Lost,'" our source said. "It was by far and away the best thing in the room in my opinion, followed by 'Grey's Anatomy.' I didn't think I was going to be able to make it through 'Rome.' That show is absolutely stroke inducing. A minute more and I would have cracked."

(NOTE: These reports come to us unsolicited. We pass them along when we know the sources to be usually credible, but information is unofficial and unverified. We stress that this is merely one person's opinion and may not reflect the group's consensus. Also, we do not encourage judges to break any agreement of confidentiality that they may have made with ATAS.)