Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

OSCARS POLL - VOTE: Who was the sorest loser?

November 26, 2007 | 10:13 am

My journo pal Tariq Khan is a shrewd Oscarologist who can rattle off the names of every past contender in any category. I asked him to apply his amazing recall powers to giving us his list of 10 sorest losers since 1990. Below is text by Tariq. Do you agree? Vote in our poll. Note that some names you might expect to find here are missing, like Eddie Murphy ("Dreamgirls"), who reportedly stormed out of the ceremony after he lost, even refusing to stick around to see his "Dreamgirls" costars perform. Tariq based his list upon what reax we see on the TV screen as soon as winners were announced. At that point, Murphy was caught smiling politely and even clapping when Alan Arkin's name was announced.

Sorestoscarloser

1.) Samuel L. Jackson, best supporting actor nominee of 1994 for "Pulp Fiction" — losing to Martin Landau for "Ed Wood." I give Mr. Jackson the top spot because he's the only nominee I've ever seen say the "s" word when he lost. It was quite visible. Surely he knew that he would lose to Landau, who had won virtually every other award leading up to the Oscars. Forget about what they call a Big Mac or Quarter Pounder with Cheese in French — what do they call a sore loser? A sore loser royale?

2.) Bill Murray, best-actor nominee of 2003 for "Lost in Translation" — losing to Sean Penn for "Mystic River." He looked devastated before Nicole Kidman even opened the envelope, and his expression didn't change when she called out Penn's name. Afterwards, host Billy Crystal asked Murray not to leave, and the audience gave him a nice round of applause, to console him.

3.) Denzel Washington, best-actor nominee of 1999 for "The Hurricane" — losing to Kevin Spacey for "American Beauty." Poor Denzel. He looked like a lock in January when he went home with the Golden Globe, but the controversy surrounding the film and its shut-out in all other Oscar categories allowed Spacey to leap ahead of him in the final weeks of the race. You could see Denzel's heart sink when Gwyneth Paltrow named Spacey the victor. Denzel turned to see Spacey's reaction, gently clapping but unable to muster up a smile. Talk about a hurricane victim.

4.) Diane Ladd, best supporting actress nominee of 1991 for "Rambling Rose" — losing to Mercedes Ruehl for "The Fisher King." Ladd hoped the third time would be the charm. She clutched a red rose as her name was announced as a nominee. When Joe Pesci declared Ruehl the winner, Ladd looked pissed. I mean, she was dressed in white, but you could see the red.

CLICK HERE to Continue Reading the List of OSCAR'S SOREST LOSERS!

5.) Ian McKellen, best supporting actor nominee of 2001 for "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" — losing to Jim Broadbent for "Iris." McKellen had put on a good face when he lost to Roberto Benigni for best actor of 1998. But this time, he sat expressionless as he lost to fellow Brit Broadbent. He presented on stage with Maggie Smith shortly afterwards, and he still appeared to be steaming. (However, later in the show, the camera showed him being consoled by a much younger man holding his hand.)

6.) Kathy Bates, best supporting actress nominee of 2002 for "About Schmidt" — losing to Catherine Zeta-Jones for "Chicago." Okay, so maybe she wasn't so much more sore as she was confused. When presenter Sean Connery opened the envelope, he simply said "Catherine," referring to Mrs. Michael Douglas. (Connery starred with her in 1999's "Entrapment," so the two probably had some sort of bond.) When Bates heard Connery call out the first name only, she looked dumbfounded, as if to say "Catherine who???" Bates must have thought that Connery might have been referring to her (although her full name is actually Kathleen.) She turned in the direction where all the exuberant "Chicago" nominees were seated, and the camera cut to the beaming, pregnant Catherine Z.

7.) Robert Duvall, best-actor nominee of 1997 for "The Apostle," losing to Jack Nicholson for "As Good As It Gets." Duvall looked down as Frances McDormand opened the envelope, as if quietly praying for a second Oscar. (He had won for "Tender Mercies" 14 years earlier.) When Nicholson won for the third time, Duvall looked like he had completely lost all faith.

8.) Lauren Bacall, best supporting actress nominee of 1996 for "The Mirror Has Two Faces" — losing to Juliette Binoche for "The English Patient." Frontrunner Bacall told Joan Rivers on the red carpet that "There are always surprises, and I'm waiting for someone else's name to be called out." Unfortunately for Bacall, she was right. Kevin Spacey looked right at her before he opened the envelope, and Bacall looked like she had been slapped when Binoche's name was called. Bacall did manage to clap, while her son seated next to her visibly gasped. Later in the telecast, the camera turned to Bacall, still looking like she wanted to kill herself - though she did seem to come back to life when the Coen brothers won the original screenplay Oscar for "Fargo."

9.) Judy Davis, best supporting actress nominee of 1992 for "Husbands and Wives" — losing to Marisa Tomei for "My Cousin Vinny." One of the biggest Oscar upsets in history, though Davis might have been even more upset when presenter Jack Palance identified her as being English. (Davis is Australian.) You could see her quietly say "I'm not English, I'm not English," as she shrugged. When Palance declared Tomei the winner, you could see Davis raise her eyebrows in shock. Fellow nominees Joan Plowright and Vanessa Redgrave actually laughed at Tomei's win, while Miranda Richardson seemed to think that Palance was starting to say her name. (Marisa, Miranda - they start out sounding the same.)

10.) Geoffrey Rush, best-actor nominee of 2000 for "Quills" — losing to Russell Crowe for "Gladiator." This is one that I don't quite get. Rush probably knew that he had zero chance of winning, but whom was he rooting for? He looked very unhappy when Hilary Swank announced Crowe's name. Rush's wife turned to him as if to say, "Oh well, too bad." But really, whom did he want to win?

(Photos: Miramax / Focus Features)

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments

What about when Tom Cruise lost for Born on 4th of July, he so should have won that one.

How about Eddie Murphy losing for Dreamgirls? He took his girlfriend and stormed out.


But, nothing can beat the old Hollywood guard like Rosalind Russel or Shelley Winters, who stood up to accept their awards, even though somebody else had won.

You most defiitely forgot Eddie Murphy for Dreamgirls!

Samuel L. Jackson should have fumed when the nominees were announced. He should have got a best actor nod, NOT TRAVOLTA!!!!

No Eddie Murphy?! He actually left when he didn't win! Now THATS a sore loser

You're forgetting Nick Nolte losing to Roberto Benigni in 1999. Nolte looked like he was going to kill someone.

My vote goes to Jane Fonda, who was livid that "Coming Home" lost the Best Picture Oscar to "The Deer Hunter". Talking to the press afterward, she spouted off how "The Deer Hunter" was propaganda, the Pentagon's version of the war, etc.

A reporter asked whether she'd seen the movie, and she replied, "No, but I know ours was better."

If that isn't graceless losing, I don't know what is.

For me the biggest upset was Denzel Washington losing for "Malcolm X" to Al Pacino for "Scent of a Woman". This is one of the many examples where the Academy gave the Oscar to the one who was, in their eyes, "overdue", instead of to the best in that category.

How about the writer for Brokeback Mountain? Bitching in the press when the movie lost BP to Crash that the industry was 'homophobic'. Or was Crash just better? Boo hoo.

The one I remember best was Nick Nolte..sulking in a black tuxedo...
Do not remember year or which nomination...
Anyone does?

No. Annie Proulx may have been sore but she was right. Crash was trash. But trash that pushed all the right buttons while Brokeback required a more nuanced, less geriatric, less conservative understanding. Guess which movie will be remembered 30 years from now?

Like someone already said, how about a 'best winner' list? My top choice would be (although I don't like him as an actor) Joe Pesci, who had the very best speech of all: a simple, straightforward and not-full-of-hot-air 'Thank you'!

what about robert downey jr. in 1992 with chaplin?al pacino was good but he is good in all his films...downey deserved it

The one that sticks out most in my mind is when Kate Winslet (Titanic) lost to Helen Hunt (As Good as it Gets) in 1998. Nothing was more priceless than the look of utter disgust on the Titanic's starlet's face as if to say "I got naked for this?"

You (in the US) don't remember the sorest loser of all, Fernanda Montenegro, who said to brazilian press that she lost the Oscar to a 'blonde bimbo' (in the case, it was Gwyneth Paltrow) because 'she was old and the winner was beautiful'. Afterward she won the Oscar.. in a brazilian soap opera. Consolation prize?

When the absent Michael Caine won for HANNAH AND HER SISTERS, Tom Berenger looked scarily like his psycho soldier in PLATOON, he was ready to kill.

Imelda Staunton for "Vera Drake" lost to Hilary Swank?????
What was that?

And what about Winona Ryder? The pissed look on her face when Anna Paquin's name was announced? It was like "what?how dare they give an infant MY OSCAR!"
I'm also sure that Annette Bening is plotting to kill Hlary Swank. Not one, but two times defeated!

I also don't blame Eddie Murphy either - not after the totally unprofessional negative campaign by that blogger - was it Jeffrey Wells?

I think "shit" was a refreshing & appropriate response - that's Samuel L. Jackson for you, unafraid to be honest. I like Billy Wilder's trip trick, too.

Burt Reynolds losing for Boogie Nights. The jaw clenched hard and you could see that he thought he was going to win. Oh well at least we got him back as a lead in straight to video movies.

Sally Kirkland should have been in there... she campaigned for the nomination, and when she actually got it, she thought she had a chance - even though the nomination WAS the award. She convinced herself she'd win - and she looked so bitchy when she lost!

Too bad this list is limited to actors. I would niominate Annie Proulx as sorest loser for her undignified whining in The Guardian after Brokeback Mountain lost to Crash for Best Picture in 2006.

http://film.guardian.co.uk/oscars2006/story/0,,1727312,00.html

Did everyone forget about everyones reaction when Halle Berry won? Those were the most painted on smiles I think I've ever seen.

Great article... I'd love to see some accompanying YouTube clips though!

 


Stay Connected:


Advertisement

About the Blogger


The Dish Rag
Pop & Hiss
Notes on a Season
The Circuit: Awards and Festivals News



Categories


Archives