Caught up with our Buzzmeter pundit Dave Karger of Entertainment Weekly backstage at the Gotham Awards where we did some dishing of Oscarmania. Dave explains why he took "Charlie Wilson's War" out of his top five for best pic, plus why he currently believes so strongly in "Atonement," "No Country for Old Men," "American Gangster," "Kite Runner" and "Juno." He's even, privately, rooting for one film — and it's not "Sweeney Todd"! (Quelle Horreur!) Which one is it? And why does he love it soooo? Watch below!

(Camera by Paul Sheehan)