Tonys 2009: Can Katie upstage Nicole on Broadway?
Word comes via the Daily Mail that the third Mrs. Tom Cruise, Katie Holmes, is in talks to make her Broadway debut this fall in a prestige production of Arthur Miller's "All My Sons." Two-time Tony winner John Lithgow and two-time Oscar winner Dianne Wiest will play the parents of her World War II pilot boyfriend, who crashed after hearing of his father's imprisonment for war profiteering.
With such star-studded support, all under the sure hand of acclaimed British actor/director Simon McBurney, Holmes, who has not acted on the stage since high school, could do well. In the surprisingly small world of show biz, McBurney's most recent acting job was as one of Nicole Kidman's minions in "The Golden Compass."
Ten years ago, Kidman won a Theater World award for her Broadway debut in "The Blue Room." That sizzling adaptation by David Hare of Arthur Schnitzler's "La Ronde" was a showcase for Kidman and her co-star Iain Glen. Each played five roles in a circular story of love and lust that required them both to strip down. Though they and the play got good reviews, the hoopla turned off Tony voters, who snubbed the show.
Audiences certainly won't see as much of Holmes when she plays the prim and proper Ann Deever. However, as her character is the catalyst for the family feud that has the surviving son challenging his father, she will get a chance to show off her acting chops. And by making her debut in a stage classic, Holmes could have an edge over Kidman when it comes to awards season. Those appearing in revivals of previous Tony winners often nab nominations.
The play was Miller's first success, following the failure three years earlier of the inaptly named "The Man Who Had All the Luck," which ran for a mere four performances. When "All My Sons" debuted on Broadway in 1947, it won Tonys for both the playwright and the director, Elia Kazan, as well as the New York Drama Critics Circle award, edging out Eugene O'Neill's epic, "The Iceman Cometh."
Forty years later, the only Rialto remount won the Tony for best revival, and Richard Kiley and Jamey Sheridan, as feuding father and son, were both nominated for Tonys. In that production, Jayne Atkinson, now known for her work on "24," made her Broadway debut as Ann.
The meaty role had been originated by Lois Wheeler and was played in the 1948 film by Louisa Horton, a noted Broadway actress making her film debut. Horton put her budding career on hold after marrying director George Roy Hill in 1951. Headlining that film were Edward G. Robinson and Burt Lancaster. In the 1986 telefilm, James Whitmore and Aidan Quinn took on these roles while Joan Allen played the part of Ann.




Am I the only person confused by this blurb? Is Nicole Kidman doing something on Broadway? How would Katie be upstaging her otherwise?
Posted by: martin | March 30, 2008 at 04:29 PM
It was Joan Allen, not Karen Allen who played Ann in the 1986 Teleplay.
Posted by: Patrick Spreng | March 30, 2008 at 11:50 AM
Kidman naked on stage,prompted her then-husband Tom Cruise to call her performance "Pure theatrical Viagra"!
Lovely.
Posted by: Cheerful man | March 29, 2008 at 09:53 PM
Is this a joke? Katie Holmes couldn't hold her own in Mad Money. What in the world makes you think she could nab a Tony nod?! Is the Cruise/Holmes people paying you to write this nonsense?! Julianne Moore bombed on Broadway recently and Holmes doesn't have 1/100th the talent of Moore. Enough said.
Posted by: eva | March 29, 2008 at 12:28 PM
ARe you kidding...Katie Holmes is like watching paing dry......Its scary enough to see Nicole with a face that doesnt move....WOW? Try acting...Now I know Katie married Tom....But that was a deal...Perhaps to further her career? Money? At what price do you sell out.....Don't insult those that actually understand the actor.....Her nose has already been done...And she just doesnt have the goods.........They re plenty of actors that really can act.......Get a grip...
Posted by: rachael weiss | March 29, 2008 at 08:35 AM
are y ou kidding me???? This is newsworthy? You need to find yourself a hobby, mr. o'neil....normally, I enjoy your column and your giddiness to all things award-worthy, but this is really stretching it....
Posted by: michael | March 29, 2008 at 07:08 AM
Katie Holmes on stage? Big yawn.
Posted by: Mia | March 29, 2008 at 06:30 AM