Producers Guild of America hails 'Slumdog Millionaire' as best picture
"Slumdog Millionaire" just leapt ahead on the derby track toward a likey big win at the Oscars by being voted best picture by the Producers Guild of America.
Over the past 19 years, PGA has correctly forecast best picture at the Academy Awards 12 times. However, most of that agreement was in earlier years. The Oscars and PGA Awards agreed last year on "No Country for Old Men," but they disagreed the previous three years.
Some kudos watchers believed that the guild would automatically pick "The Dark Knight" as best picture because producers care a lot about their films' succeeding financially. "The Dark Knight" was not only the top-earning movie of 2008 ($531 million in the U.S., $997 million worldwide), but the second-biggest-grossing pic of all time, surpassed only by "Titantic" ($1.8 billion worldwide in 1997).
But "Slumdog Millionaire" is a fantastic financial success in other ways. Produced for only $14 million, it's already grossed $48 million in the U.S. and will probably exceed $80 million in toto. Overseas, it's likely to match that performance. As a business venture, "Slumdog Millionaire" is providing an extraordinary return on investment.
Futhermore, "Slumdog Millionaire" is a financial fairy tale that's irresistable in Hollywood as a real story of the triumph of a true underdog. Just last year the film was slated to go straight to DVD after the demise of Warner Independent, but it was miraculously rescued by Fox Searchlight, the most successful indie branch of Hollwood's big studios.
Producers may often be considered cold-hearted biz cats, but they've shown glimpses of warm hearts and romantic spirits when deciding past awards. In 2001, voters made the surprising choice of "Moulin Rouge!" over "A Beautiful Mind." In 1992, they picked "The Crying Game" over "Unforgiven."
Here's how our pundits fared predicting what film would win tonight at the Hollywood Palladium gala.
Below is a comparison between the PGA and Oscars' choices of best picture on a year-by-year basis.
BEST PICTURE WINNERS: OSCARS VS. PGA AWARDS
2007
"No Country for Old Men" - PGA, Oscar
2006
"Little Miss Sunshine" - PGA
"The Departed" - Oscar
2005
"Brokeback Mountain" - PGA
"Crash" - Oscar
2004
"The Aviator" - PGA
"Million Dollar Baby" - Oscar
2003
"Lord of the Rings: Return of the King" - PGA, Oscar
2002
"Chicago" - PGA, Oscar
2001
"Moulin Rouge!" - PGA
"A Beautiful Mind" - Oscar
2000
"Gladiator" - PGA, Oscar
1999
"American Beauty" - PGA, Oscar
1998
"Saving Private Ryan" - PGA
"Shakespeare in Love" - Oscar
1997
"Titantic" - PGA, Oscar
1996
"The English Patient" - PGA, Oscar
1995
"Apollo 13" - PGA
"Braveheart" - Oscar
1994
"Forrest Gump" - PGA, Oscar
1993
"Schindler's List" - PGA, Oscar
1992
"The Crying Game" - PGA
"Unforgiven" - Oscar
1991
"The Silence of the Lambs" - PGA, Oscar
1990
"Dances with Wolves" - PGA, Oscar
1989
"Driving Miss Daisy" - PGA, Oscar
RELATED STORIES
See Which Films Our Pundits Predicted Would Win Best Picture at PGA Awards -
'Push' Ties Two Award Records at the Sundance Film Festival
17 Experts Predict Who'll Win the SAG Awards -
Dueling Pundits Predict Who'll Win the SAG Awards -
Oscars Quiz: Who Wrote the Most Best Pictures? -
Photo: Fox Searchlight
Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.




Why do I keep reading about 'Titantic' on this blog? I thought it was called 'Titanic'.
Posted by: Tim | January 25, 2009 at 04:13 PM
Tom, correct me if I'm wrong (you're the man with all the numbers), but I thought LotR: Return of the King was the second biggest grossing picture of all time, when it came to worldwide box office.
The Dark Night was the second biggest grossing picture in the American domestic market, but not worldwide.
Posted by: Bill | January 25, 2009 at 01:54 PM