Anne Hathaway could contend at Oscars and Tonys for playing Judy Garland
If you thought Anne Hathaway was brave for singing and dancing with Hugh Jackman on the recent Oscarcast, that was a walk in the park compared with her next performance — playing Judy Garland on both stage and screen. The Oscar-nominated actress ("Rachel Getting Married") is to star in upcoming film and legit adaptations of Gerald Clarke's 2000 biography "Get Happy: The Life of Judy Garland."
With the Weinstein Co. producing both these properties, Anne Hathaway is in good hands. While there is no word as to any of the other creatives involved in these projects, the source material is rich with possibilities, including as it does material in Judy Garland's own words. Gerald Clarke's biography of the late, great writer Truman Capote was the basis for "Capote," which was nominated for five awards at the 2005 Oscars including best picture and won lead actor for Philip Seymour Hoffman.
If Hathaway can pull this part off, she would be a leading contender at both the Oscars and the Tonys. Seven of the last 10 women to win lead actress at the Academy Awards did so by playing real-life roles. The irony of course is that Judy Garland never won a competitive Oscar. In 1939, she was awarded an honorary one for her timeless performance in "The Wizard of Oz."
However, she lost both of her Oscar races. In 1954, Judy Garland made one of the all-time great screen comebacks, proving herself a triple threat with her acting, singing and dancing in the musical remake of "A Star Is Born." So sure was the academy that she would win the lead actress Oscar that they set up a television camera in Judy's hospital room where she was resting after having given birth to son Joey just days before. However, it was Grace Kelly's name that was announced, for her role as the dutiful wife to an alcoholic actor (Bing Crosby) in "The Country Girl." And while Judy Garland was nominated for her 1961 supporting performance as a witness in "Judgment at Nuremberg," she lost to Rita Moreno for "West Side Story."
Judy Garland never appeared in a Broadway musical in her all-too-short life. In 1967, she was so eager to take over from Tony winner Angela Lansbury in "Mame" that she watched the show from the wings for nights on end. However, the producers could not get the insurance to cover the costs should Garland not appear. She did win an honorary Tony Award in 1952 for "for an important contribution to the revival of vaudeville through her recent stint at the Palace Theatre."
Broadway usually favors the fanciful over the fact-driven, though the last two Tonys for lead actress in a musical went to hopefully heightened portrayals of real-life women — Christine Ebersole ("Grey Gardens") and Patti Lupone ("Gypsy"). While Hathaway has never appeared on Broadway, in 2002 she tackled a Tony-winning role for five performances of a concert version of the 1961 musical "Carnival." As the orphaned Lili (a part that earned Anna Maria Alberghetti the lead actress award), Hathaway shone opposite Tony winner Brian Stokes Mitchell ("Kiss Me Kate"). This summer, Hathway is to star in a production of "Twelfth Night" as part of the Public Theatre's celebrated Shakespeare in the Park series in New York's Central Park.
The big question is whether Anne Hathaway will sing the songs so associated with Judy Garland or mime along to recordings. In 2001, both Tammy Blanchard and Judy Davis won Emmy Awards for playing Judy Garland in the mini-series "Me and My Shadows." They both lip synced to Judy's unique song stylings. In 2004 Isabel Keating earned a Tony nomination as featured actress in a musical for her portrayal of Garland in "The Boy From Oz." She lost to Anika Noni Rose for "Caroline or Change."
While Isabel Keating performed musical numbers as Judy, she was not singing Garland songs. Rather, as the musical told the story of one-time Garland son-in-law Peter Allen, she sang some of his tunes. And bringing this item full circle, Hugh Jackman won the lead actor in a musical Tony Award for playing the singer-songwriter once married to Liza Minnelli.
Below is a clip of Judy Garland singing the Oscar-winning "Over the Rainbow" during a 1943 radio broadcast of the morale-boosting "Command Performance." She is introduced by Bob Hope who had featured the young singer on his radio show during the 1939 season. Four years later, Garland had become one of the biggest stars on the MGM lot.
(Photo courtesy Stephen Lovekin/Getty Images)
RELATED POSTS:
Can 'Sopranos' Emmy champ James Gandolfini win a Tony Award?
Will 'West Side Story' be slighted by the Tony Awards yet again?
'Extraordinary' Natasha Richardson was beloved Broadway star
Can Angela Lansbury tie Tony record with a fifth win for 'Blithe Spirit'?
Is 'Irena's Vow' the next Holocaust awards champ?
Jane Fonda is Tony Award front-runner for '33 Variations'
Olivier Awards to 'Black Watch' and the Bard
Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.



as much as I love Anne Hathaway and respect her acting and talent in general, I am also a huge Judy Garland fan and have studied her for years and think this project of casting Anne as Judy Garland is a major casting disaster waiting to happen. They need to find a no name triple threat actress to portray Judy as to not overshadow the raw story of Judy's life. Anne doesn't look anything like Judy and has not been known for her dancing and vocal skills. HEARING ANNE HATHAWAY HAD BEEN CAST TO PORTRAY JUDY GARLAND IS ACTUALLY UPSETTING AND BELIEVE THIS PROJECT WILL NOT BE NEARLY AS SUCCESSFUL IF CASTING WOULD JUST DO THE WORK TO FIND A QUALITY, NO NAME TRIPLE THREAT ACTRESS TO PORTRAY JUDY AND TELL THE STORY OF HER LIFE EFFECTIVELY.
Posted by: Diana | July 25, 2009 at 11:16 AM
I think that Zooey Deschanel should have been picked to play Judy Garland. Have you heard her sing? She has a great Judy Garland singing voice.
Posted by: Cathy-Anne | May 10, 2009 at 04:55 PM
When something is not broken, no need to fix, I totally disagree with your choice of who will portray Judy Garland, Tammy Blanchard is the one who should have been selected, she was a perfect match in all aspects.
Posted by: karen Colins | May 02, 2009 at 08:29 AM
Re: Anne H. resembling the young Liza M., accidentally deleted the follow-up sentence: Given the often noted visual similarities between Liza and her mother, it would seem to put Anne in good stead to at least approximate Judy.
Posted by: dorothy | April 02, 2009 at 11:39 PM
No resemblance to Garland? Hello? At certain points in "Rachel Getting Married," Anne Hathaway bore an uncanny resemblance to the young Liza Minnelli. Marion Cotillard didn't do her own singing as Piaf, and she's also taller than her character was in real life. As for being a mediocre singer, not true: she was marvelous, clear as a bell in the City Center "Carnival!," and just fine belting out "What More Do I Need?" at the Sondheim 75th birthday celebration at the Bowl some years back.
To write off Ms. Hathaway as Garland before she's even done the role says far more about the people doing so than it does about her potential in part.
That said, if she's a natural for any movie musical, after this year's Oscars it would clearly be as Julie Jordan opposite Hugh Jackman's Billy Bigelow, should his option on "Carousel" actually lead to a filmed remake. (First choice as Carrie Pipperidge: Amanda Seyfried, of course).
Posted by: dorothy | April 02, 2009 at 10:18 PM
I'm sorry, i do not think Anne Hathaway is the right person to play Judy. The voice also is mediocre but besides that the Me and My Shadows was so perfect. Where's the nedd so soon? Leave Judy in peace please, lets just enjoy her films and cd's and leave her alone. They've made enough money out of her.
Posted by: joanna | April 01, 2009 at 05:57 PM
i think that the academy stole her the nomination for brokeback mountain i think we need to see if she can handle the pressure of portray judy garland and she so many times have been compare with her but she sing very well ayt the oscar and i have done here in brazil reviews of her films and i think she is a good actress. i really like her she will be good i have heard that she study theater , that is something at her favor.
Posted by: ayrton valles | March 30, 2009 at 03:54 PM
i like her
Posted by: ayrton valles | March 30, 2009 at 03:46 PM
i think this could be great, but if you look up clips of liza pre-cabaret on the judy show i think anne looks more like her
Posted by: BSAUL | March 30, 2009 at 02:32 PM
i love anne hathaway and i think the academy stole her the nomination for brokeback mountain but if she lead a good performance i just will said is oscar time for anne
Posted by: ayrton valles | March 27, 2009 at 12:48 PM
i am agree with the first comment anne hathaway is a good actress and i think the academy stole her the nomination for brokeback mountain but is to early to said she will be a strong contender althougt if she handle this good i can bet she will won the oscar
Posted by: ayrton valles | March 27, 2009 at 12:43 PM
Why are we already calling her a contender for an Oscar and a Tony when she hasn't actually done anything with this yet? I like Anne Hathaway but this is a bit premature.
Posted by: Andrew | March 25, 2009 at 03:52 AM
Just doesn't seem right.
Sorry. She bears no resemblance. They should use the french girl who played Edith Piaf.
Posted by: basementfrog | March 24, 2009 at 09:55 AM
Anne's about 5'8". Judy was 4'11". So I think she's the wrong choice for this role.
Posted by: Nel | March 24, 2009 at 09:32 AM
I like Anne Hathaway and I am very interested how she will handle this role both on stage and screen. However this is just pure Oscar bait (Harvey!).
Posted by: SkyLight | March 23, 2009 at 10:44 PM