The Envelope Logo

Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Will 'High School Musical 4' be a real winner too?

March 4, 2009 |  2:12 pm

When the "High School Musical" franchise was launched on the Disney Channel, the first few installments did fairly well in the awards derby. The dance-a-thons got tripped up, though, when part three headed to movie theaters as a feature film, forsaking a first run on cable TV like the first two parts. It earned $250 million worldwide, but didn't fare well with awards.

"High School Musical 4" will return to TV and — yikes — not star Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens. Curiously, it may not even include Kenny Ortega, the director of the first three installments. Word is still out on that. Writer Peter Barsocchini will pick up his pen again, though, and its original producers will return.


According to the Disney news release, new stars will be cast as leads and "High School Musical 4" will feature a love triangle "set against the cross-town rivalry between the East High Wildcats and West High Knights."

The original "High School Musical" was nominated for six primetime Emmys and won two. It beat "Dancing With the Stars" for best choreography and tied HBO's "I Have Tourette's but Tourette's Doesn't Have Me" for best children's program. It also won best children's programming at the awards bestowed by the Television Critics Assn.

At the Teen Choice Awards, the original "High School Musical" won best TV comedy/musical show, Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens won best chemistry. However, in the individual category for best breakout stars,  Zac beat Vanessa! But, hey, he also clobbered Miley Cyrus ("Hannah Montana"), so he wasn't just picking on poor Vanessa!

One year later, "High School Musical 2" was nominated for best children's program at the Emmys again, but got clobbered by "Nick News With Linda Ellerbee" and HBO's "Classical Baby." Its only other nomination was for best choreography, but it lost to "So You Think You Can Dance."

At the Kids' Choice Awards, part two nabbed only one nomination: best TV movie, which it won, beating "Life Is Not a Fairy Tale: The Fantasia Barrino Story" and "Jump In," a Disney Channel film about a wannabe boxer who leaps into a jump-rope competition while chasing a girl.

Director Kenny Ortega won the Directors Guild of America Award for the first installment, but "High School Musical 2" lost to "Jump In!"

At TCA, part two lost best children's programming to the educational cartoon show "WordGirl" on PBS.

When "High School Musical 3: Senior Year" came out, it competed for film awards, not TV, since it was a feature release. The only kudos nibble it got was from a crafts guild, the Motion Picture Sound Editors, which nominated it in a category for musicals. It lost to "Mamma Mia!"

Photos: Disney


Zac Efron named breakthrough performer of the year by theater owners

Can "High School Musical 3" graduate to movie awards?

Will Zac Efron wow Oscars viewers?

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.

The comments to this entry are closed.


i hope the cast will still remain or it will have a high school musica;watever part it is but the theme is the reunion of the original cast...hope kenny ortega or disney employees can read this...if zac and vanessa will be together until the end...hope it will happen...hate the new cast they cant sing but they can only dance... i like the chemistry of you vanessa hudgens

hey i love zac and vanessa so much i am your BIGGEST fan please be in HSM4

i loved high school musical 3!
i love zac and vanessa sooo much!
so sad they might not be in hsm4

please dont do this i really want to see the original stars please zac and vanessa please do hsm4 i am all ready your biggest fans ever do it for ALL your fans i really want to see your chemistry together again and please stay together as a real couple you belong with each other i love u so much PLEASE!!!!! High school musical 4 is not going to be the same with out you and the other stars please

thats stupid high schpool musical 1,2,and3 were fine and they dont need to replace any one

are Zac and Vanessa still dating in real life

Since when did 'awards' translate into success. Last time I checked none of the 'experts' not even the ones at Disney saw HSM being the blockbuster it was. You could've done a better analysis by comparing album sales (which have trickled off). It's a lot safer to say that the public is losing interest than to say they movies are no good because the 'critics' say so.

i loved there movie it was so nice and fantastic i am there biggest fans ever



In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Blogger

Pop & Hiss



In Case You Missed It...