After 'American Idol': Will Adam Lambert or Kris Allen win the most awards?
Never mind who will win "American Idol" next week. Will Kris Allen or Adam Lambert emerge as the biggest winner in the future when judging their music careers?
Remember, Jennifer Hudson merely came in seventh place in Season 3 of "American Idol," but now her house is sinking under the weight of all those awards on her mantle, including an Oscar and Golden Globe ("Dreamgirls") plus Grammy ("Jennifer Hudson").
Hey, where's Ruben Studdard today? And let's be honest: Taylor Hicks is lucky to have a spot in the road tour of "Grease" after everybody in America decided not to buy his CDs. By comparison: After Taylor Hicks won in 2006, the band behind the fourth-place finisher, Chris Daughtry, went on to score four Grammy nominations and win four American Music Awards.
Of course, sometimes the "American Idol" winner actually does โ egads โ become successful, trophies and all. First-year champ Kelly Clarkson has claimed a few Grammys, MTV Video Music Awards, American Music Awards, Teen Choice Awards, even a People's Choice Award. Season 4 victor Carrie Underwood won best new artist at the Grammys plus gads of country music prizes.
A few months ago, when the current season of "American Idol" was still unfurling, I asked this question about the top 10 finalists: Who'll go on to win the most showbiz awards?
Kris Allen merely came in sixth place in our Gold Derby poll, with 4.6% of the vote. Ahead of him were: Adam Lambert (53.8%), Allison Iraheta (13.2%), Danny Gokey (7.9%), Matt Giraud (7.3%) and Lil Rounds (4.8%). Now what do you think, my dear Derbyites?
RELATED POST
Which 'American Idol' star will win the most showbiz awards?
Photos: Fox TV
Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.



Adam is inspiring while kris is boring. adam got personality while kris got none. like elvis vs pat boone. ELVIS WENT ON TO BE A LEGENDARY FIGURE. millions still remember him and cry at his anniversary . pat? I do not notice. I think got some christmas songs. is he around?
its time for ADAM to spice up our lives. for those who like kris type. there are so many better current ones in the market. its too saturated. for new ones i much prefer the 2 davids anytime. but THERE IS AND WILL BE ONLY ONE ADAM LAMBERT FOR MEMORY. I do not get americans . such a talent and they still complaint. our idol in our country will never be able to match ADAM .
Posted by: lady | June 07, 2009 at 08:30 AM
I'm not sure just where all this bias is coming from. In this, like all things, there are two schools of thought. Adam is great performer; Kris is a better musician. Adam is an entertaing showman; Kris is an engaging artist. I don't wish anything bad for Adam. But I do prefer Kris' style. I think Kris winning should not be too hard to understand. When you look at the Wednesday night final show, they paired both Kris and Adam with famous acts to showcase their two styles. Adam was showcased with Kiss and they are a legendary group. I was impressed with this performance, but it looked like it belonged 30 years ago. Kris sang with Keith Urban, who is certainly much more contemporary. All season, the judges kept flattering Adam every step of the way by saying how "current" and 'right now" he is, and they present him with Kiss. I don't have major problems with Adam at all, but I absolutely think Kris deserves his win. For those of you who may wonder, no, I don't live in Arkansas and I am not a thirteen year old. I'm an adult from Ohio and many of my friends have supported Kris. I really do wish the best for both Kris and Adam. But, I do resent all the sentiment that Kris does not deserve this title. He certainly does!
Posted by: KPAX | June 04, 2009 at 08:27 PM
Adam your kindness to Kris and expression of congratulations is indeed something that would make America proud. You are a very confident individual and this alone will allow you to go beyond your highest dreams. You are the most talented individual that has come our way in years. Your success will prove to everyone you are a true super star ... Simon is right you will always get a standing ovation from the world. Congratulations !!!! You will be "world famous"!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Maria | June 04, 2009 at 06:37 PM
Adam's professionalism, gentleness, modesty and pureness exudes above and beyond all others. Not once did he forget to thank his audience or band members. Not once did he forget who he is. Your talent and your sense of responsibility is overwhelming - add to this the most superb acts of all times...voice, look, sensitivity, gestures, eye contact and expression and you have a "super star" - one that we have not seen in ages. Beatles, Elvis, Springstein, Queen, Kiss, among a few...you have met a "compadre". Love you Adam the best to you today and always.
Posted by: Maria | June 04, 2009 at 06:30 PM
I was so angry when Kris won and you could tell Simon was not happy either. I probably won't watch AI anymore because I am convinced it is fixed. In my opinion Adam is the greatest performer since Axl Rose and for me that is saying plenty. His career will far outshine Kris' and who cares about his personal life? Not me. He could be a martian for all I care. It wouldn't change how amazingly talented he is. Everyone I know from 14 to 70 thinks he should have won and there are alot of us, so who are all the people that voted for Kris because I don't know any. When Adam is 60 and still rockin out like Steven Tyler. Kris will be a has-been on the oldies circuit . I am a huge fan and I am proud to say so.
Posted by: rock fan since the fifties | June 02, 2009 at 09:12 PM
Adam was the real winner It was one big fix your votes had nothing to do with the results .they never had count backs and there was never anyway to prove who got how many votes if you go back and watch the last couple of shows . you would notice how they rigged it to make out that Adam was always in the bottom 2 in stead of picking the person with the most votes first. Seacreast knew that they could not have a GAY singer win but no one would believe that Danny could suddenly beat Adam it would cause a Storm, so they dumped Danny and shoved Kris in to make it more believeable Kris only sung one good song the whole season and he wins on one song COME PEOPLE WAKE UP
Posted by: Les | June 02, 2009 at 07:03 PM
I was totally shocked to see that Kris won and not Adam. We ALL know who has the most talent. Not bad on the eyes either.
Posted by: Gail | June 02, 2009 at 09:19 AM
What is this I hear? Kris Allen already had a record? Next year AI shouldn't allow ppl who already made records, it should look for fresh talent. ADAM IS THE TRUE WINNER regardless of what FOX or At&T say. Good job Adam will buy all your CDs before theyre sold out.
Posted by: Camille | June 01, 2009 at 01:54 PM
CHRIS IS A SO SO TALENT ADAM IS A SUPERSTAR COULD BE LEAD SINGER OF ANY ROCK BAND OUT THERE
Posted by: maria a goetz | June 01, 2009 at 01:45 PM
ADAM IS THE BEST THING SINCE ELVIS LOVE HIS MUSIC HEIS SUPERRR TALENTED
Posted by: maria a goetz | June 01, 2009 at 01:44 PM
Zach, you are crazy. Kris belong on a stage. I sure would not want to pay and go to sleep inside. And if I want to buy a CD to sleep, then I would. But think of it, there are so many singers, some even more relaxing and soothing (without the contorted face and mouth actions that is so distracting.) I mean they sing just naturally and beautifully.
I would pay to fly over there for ADAM. iN aSIA, the entertainers took GREAT CARE to produce a great show for their fans. With features, fashion and everything. BUT TO US ADAM BEATS THEM ALL! So American should proud. Yet you all still want a laid back singer who wears jeans and T shirt in the finale to represent you. Americans are so backward. No wonder they are going down down down now.
Posted by: Worldwide Fan of Adam | June 01, 2009 at 06:13 AM
Kris, sorry, this voting scam is more infamous than you winning. For 100 people voting continuously for 4 hours - the difference in votes between kRIS AND Adam can be a staggering 12 million!!! Go and do your maths. If those CHEATERS at AKANSAS got hold of these free phones and free power testing, won't they be texting continously for 4 hours?? Think about it. Or another person take over. OTHERS will have to see the amount in their bill the following month.
AT&T subscribers, terminate your contract. This AT&T will FOREVER BE A SCANDAL INVOLVING FOX. Sorry Kris, to us here, you are known as "the one that SHOULD NOT HAVE WON, but rigged by your hometown votes". How you like that? Your hometown is so famous now. But I would not like to visit there when I go USA.
Posted by: UNETHICAL VOTES | June 01, 2009 at 06:07 AM
I am going to pay someone in America to download ALL ADAM'S itunes for me. Yeah yeah, he will be so famous, David A came here to do a cover opening for McFLY. ADAM WILL COME HERE TO DO A ADAM LAMBERT SHOW. He can be with QUEEN also. That would be awesome and his portfolio will go WILD.
Oh Adam, adam, I'm looking at your news daily. Waiting for the flu to be over so that can go to see you in USA.
WITH LOTTA LOVE
SINGAPORE
INDONESIA
Posted by: Singapore | June 01, 2009 at 06:01 AM
But now AI has to contend with a million dollar contract for Kris. Of course this was not their preference. Simon was so pissed that he would not even stand and applaud to congratulate Kris. He saw the billion $$ that was Adam Lambert go out the window. With Adam as the AI winner, promotion would have been a piece of cake for Adam, where promotion for Kris is going to be a hard sell. Even now, everywhere that Adam goes, he is sought after for this pic, that autograph. After R&Kelly, the press wanted a piece of him, wanting him to pose, this way Adam, turn to your left, Adam, now look at me, Adam. He did not even flinch, you could see that Adam was born to be a star. Kris will never have that charisma or star quality of Adam. And AI will never have the star that they so desired to have. Adam is the true mega star and the whole world know it. You go, Adam.
Posted by: adamsluvjnes | May 31, 2009 at 08:43 PM
I love Kris as a person, but there is no doubt in my mind that Adam will go on to win awards and sell a lot more records long term. Kris has a pleasant voice, but he's no better than guitar players at the coffee shop near the university. People mistakenly think Adam's not current because he was SO good at bringing old songs to life. And so far as the pairing of Allen and Urban making Allen more relevant than Lambert's with Kiss... well, whose vid performance had more than 1 million hits on You tube and has been selling like crazy on Itunes? Adam Lambert's. People just want to be entertained and for the kids, glam rock IS new! LOL (I also saw that Urban commented that Lambert was the best.) I think we have only begun to see what Adam can do -- especially since AI's band could not handle the electronic/tech sound he said he wanted to try. If you had a chance to check out his own songs on YouTube (bec YES he does write his own music too), you'd have a sense of what he's talking about when he says he wants to do fusion and move music forward. He's hardly focused on the past and I for one am waiting eagerly to see what he'll do in the future.
Posted by: Camille | May 31, 2009 at 08:40 PM
I have just downloaded al of Adams performances from I-tunes so I will have the originals when he becomes extremely famous(not that he isn't already!) One of the greatest talent discoveries ever!
Posted by: anna | May 31, 2009 at 08:15 PM
Adam was clearly the better singer and deserved the win. I can't wait until his cd comes out because I'm going through Adam withdrawal. Until then, I'll be listening and watching my itunes of your perfomances.
Posted by: Tracy | May 31, 2009 at 04:41 PM
Adam is a unique, gifted, professional artist, a passionate performer who is at home on the stage - he has worked the 'hard yards' and we see today the embodiment of all that work - WOW - what a joy for us all to witness - I love his earlier classical work - in fact I love it all!
Posted by: Kate | May 31, 2009 at 02:56 PM
I could never listen to a Kris album all the way through. I'd be asleep before the first song finished.
Posted by: Brucek | May 31, 2009 at 02:27 PM
It should have been Alison vs. Adam in the finals.........btw not all teenage girls like kris almost all of my friends were pulling for adam to win. Don't worry, Kris will be gone in a few years...thank goodness
Posted by: Emily | May 31, 2009 at 02:08 PM
And how POed do you think Simon is that Adam is one that GOT AWAY! He's not bound to any contract from AI! Whoopee! he will have greater options, and greater $ rewards.
Atta boy, Adam.
Sorry Simon. Poor Simon ;-)
Posted by: grandma102 | May 31, 2009 at 01:35 PM
Laurie said "to those who miss Adam"
??? miss him ???
He's ALL OVER TV, doing spots on morning shows, drawing applause from tweens to grannies (like me). Star quality doesn't come via Simon Cowell's trophy. No indeedie, Adam's voice, stage presence, persona... nothing can stop him now. He's the greatest thing since twitter
Posted by: grandma102 | May 31, 2009 at 01:30 PM
To those who miss Adam, I watch his videos over and over again (mesmerized), I listen to his studio recorded songs in the car, etc. so I'm an official Adam Addict. Can't wait for new shows and albums!
Posted by: Laurie | May 31, 2009 at 11:52 AM
Since Adam did ot get the crown Idol, Adam should earn a lot of awards in music industry. What Adam need is get his CD out there and make it a HIT one.
To those commented about Adam's type of music, I don't think he will be recording the super Hi-notes for his CD. If you moron listen to Adam what type of music he will be recording to his album, you will stop that whine about his music. Honestly download all his iTunes song and you will luv Adam even more. I certainly enjoys listening to his music over and over again. Adam so far is far successful than Kris.
Posted by: Amanda | May 31, 2009 at 10:54 AM
OK, now we have a full-blown scandal on our hands:
http://smashgods.com/2009/05/27/idol-gate-conspiracy-is-american-idol-tampering-with-votes/
What is this competition coming to?
Posted by: Casey | May 28, 2009 at 09:06 AM