Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

'What Goes Up' could finally land Hilary Duff a worst actress Razzie Award

May 29, 2009 |  1:54 pm

After losing three consecutive worst actress bids at the Razzie Awards, it looks like Hilary Duff has a real shot at taking home that honor this year for her performance in "What Goes Up." This coming-of-age comedy set against the backdrop of the Challenger space shuttle tragedy opened today to some of the worst reviews of the year so far.

Hilary Duff What Goes Up Razzie Awards The film by first-time writer-director Jonathan Glatzer earned a mere 17 at Metacritic, which the aggregating site characterizes as representing critical "dislike or disgust." However, that score stands far above the absolute zero that "What Goes Up" rated with the critics surveyed by Rotten Tomatoes.

For Michael Phillips of the Chicago Tribune, "Nothing in this movie is properly focused; everyone keeps talking about a character whom we never meet and does not matter; the tone keeps slipping around from indolent satire to thudding sincerity, and the Challenger shuttle disaster backdrop is queasy-making at best, offensive at worst." Glenn Whipp of the Los Angeles Times thought, "Glatzer aims to wring laughter out of this desperation but succeeds only in producing a series of contrived characters and situations that make 'The Breakfast Club' look like an unfiltered documentary." And as Vadim Rizov said in his review for the Village Voice, "This is rock bottom: I've seen a lot of terrible movies in the line of duty, but 'What Goes Up' might be the only genuinely unreleasable one."

Hilary Duff is a four-time also-ran at the Razzie Awards, those cheeky kudos that laud the worst in moviemaking. In 2004, she lost her first worst actress bid for "A Cinderella Story" to "Catwoman" star Halle Berry, who shocked the crowd when she showed up to accept the honor. The following year, Duff was edged out for her work in "Cheaper by the Dozen 2" by "Dirty Boy" leading lady Jenny McCarthy.  In 2006, she and her equally talented sister Haylie Duff made the misfire "Material Girls." However, they lost the worst actress award to Sharon Stone ("Basic Instinct 2") and the worst couple prize to brothers Shawn and Marlon Wayans along with Kerry Washington ("Little Man").

Don't fret if you can't get to the movies to see this masterpiece. The DVD version of "What Goes Up" is already scheduled for release June 18.

RELATED POSTS

Razzies recap: 'Miss March' faces competition for worst movie of the year

Could 'Angels and Demons' bedevil Ron Howard with another Razzie nod?

Paris Hilton and 'Love Guru' lead Razzies nominations

Photo: Sony Pictures

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.

Post a comment
If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate.
Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In





Comments

She isn't a bad actress, at all. SO WTF. She did really good in this movie.. the main character (the dude) is the only one who did bad.

Read the review at Contactmusic.com this says it all and states my point. The movie is weird and unfocused NOT the actors or Ms. Duff

I don't think this is fair to say at all! From my understanding the films WRITING and DIRECTING is what's bad. Every review has said that the film is confusing and doesn't have a specific direction. This being said I DON'T think it's fair to JUDGE the actors. Yes it is the actors job to bring the characters to life and do their best with the script they have been given, and from what I have seen and read they do that. Being an actor myself I know that no matter how good you are, if the script sucks your going to suck! So lets be honest is it Ms. Duff who is bad or is it the writing and directing? I happen to think that she is a good actor, especially after seeing her on Law and Order SVU. By the way I am not a Hilary Duff fan.

i dunno why hilarys being put in the worst actress catagory. She is a great acrtess, if she wasnt she wouldnt have been so successful and she wouldnt be where she is today, shes an amazing role model and ill always be a huge fan. Love you Hilary :D, just ignore silly things like this, your AMAZING!! Keep on going Hilary! :D xoxoxoxoxox<3

i dunno why hilarys being put in the worst actress catagory. She is a great acrtess, if she wasnt she wouldnt have been so successful and she wouldnt be where she is today, shes an amazing role model and ill always be a huge fan. Love you Hilary :D, just ignore silly things like this, your AMAZING!! Keep on going Hilary! :D xoxoxoxoxox<3

How about Beyonce for Obsessed?

LOL. Dirty Boy? Is that what you are thinking? The Jenny McCarthy movie was Dirty Love!

I don't think Duff will win for this. The movie is too much of a non-entity



Stay Connected:


Advertisement

About the Blogger


The Dish Rag
Pop & Hiss
Notes on a Season
The Circuit: Awards and Festivals News



Categories


Archives