The Envelope Logo

Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Truly bold Daytime Emmy predix: 'Bold and the Beautiful' will win best drama for the first time ever

August 11, 2009 | 11:14 am

If our pundits are correct, a breakthrough will occur at the Daytime Emmys on Aug. 30. After airing 22 years on CBS, "The Bold and the Beautiful" will finally claim its first victory as best soap. "The Bold and the Beautiful" has only been nominated for the top Daytime Emmy several times and it's never been given much hope to win in the past because of its screen-time disadvantage. It's a half-hour series competing against one-hour rivals.

Susan Flannery Bold and the Beautiful

However, two gurus from our forums believe it will prevail: our moderator Matthew "Boidiva02" Cormier and poster Edward "Bamaed" Applegate. They arrived at this decision based upon careful scrutiny of the same sample episodes submitted by nominees to Emmy judges. Below, their analysis, starting first with Boidiva02. Read more noodling on this race and others in our forums.

(Ranked in likelihood of winning)
1.) "The Bold and the Beautiful" 
2.) "Days of Our Lives"
3.) "All My Children"

BOIDIVA02'S COMMENTARY: After viewing the tapes for this category, I believe that the only show worthy of a win is "The Bold and the Beautiful," which submitted two excellent episodes about the suicide of Storm Logan.

In the episodes, Katie Logan (Heather Tom) is in the hospital after being shot by her brother Storm (by accident) and needs a new heart to survive. After all possibilities have been exhausted and Katie is still without a heart, a guilt-ridden Storm takes a gun to his head and kills himself, after leaving a note expressing he wants his heart to be transplanted into his sister.  Katherine Kelly Lang as Brooke Logan is the centerpiece of these episodes. She is the one who finds Storm (her brother) following his death and is the last one to have seen him alive -- when she became angry with him, thinking he had purposely shot Katie.

The episodes use some very effective acting to make the characters come to life. A flashback sequence, which utilizes childhood home videos of him and his sisters, effectively captures Storm's anguish in making his decision to kill himself for his sister's sake. The last few moments of Storm's heart being transplanted into Katie and then finally beating are a fitting end to  an emotional hour. This is the only Emmy submission that resonates after you've watched the tapes.

"All My Children" submitted an episode in which a tornado hits Pine Valley. Although it's a good example of special effects and is done well in that regard, the overall result is boring, with too many characters  shown on screen without any powerful moments or any big effect. It could have been a masterful submission but, with special effects at center stage, no character interaction is strong enough to capture viewers' attention. The most affecting moment comes near the end of the tape, when, after the storm has passed, J.R. Chandler's wife, Babe, and son, little Adam, are trapped underneath some rubble. The only way to save little Adam is to move a piece of rubble that has trapped Babe. However, removing it would kill her. In this moment, Amanda Baker as Babe and Jacob Young as J.R. do a good job of showing an emotional current that lingers. But this lackluster tape doesn’t have any true emotional arch and fails to make a lasting impact in the way that "B&B's" tape did.

"Days of Our Lives" did a wonderful job of matching "B&B's" tape, with an episode that very well could have been produced as a prime-time drama episode. In the show, various citizens of Salem are trapped inside a plane that has been rigged with a bomb. They are losing oxygen and have almost no fuel left. They're about to crash.  During the chaos, Kayla's father, Shawn, decides to take off his oxygen mask to save it for other people, and he ends up dying because of it. This is one of a handful of affecting moments that take place on this plane. The timing is right on, and it has all the makings of a great episode, but ultimately the character interactions are just too few and far between. It's a solid effort, but I don’t think it will match "B&B's" bold choices.

Both "Days" and "Bold" make strong episode selections, and it will come down to viewer preference. Some will prefer the more heartfelt writing of "Bold" and others the more action-packed writing of "Days." In the end, I think CBS will win.   If "AMC" wins, it is not based on watching these tapes at all.

1.) "The Bold & the Beautiful"
2.) "Days of Our Lives"
3.) "All My Children"

BAMAED'S COMMENTARY: To me, this should be clear cut. All three shows sent in a spectacle but done in three completely different ways. "B&B" should win by a mile. Despite the fact that it starts off with Ronn Moss trying to emote (painful), then William deVry comes on screen and grounds everything in realism. This is true soap opera. It involves family, drama, tragedy, history and repercussions. The acting, writing and direction were spot-on perfect. The shock of Storm's suicide wasn't over the top. It was touching and sad. But to use that as a springboard to save Katie was brilliant. Katherine Kelly Long played comfortably numb to perfection. A mix of stunt with family drama, which was done well. It should win.

If "B&B" doesn't take it, "Days" should win. Another spectacle with the sabotaged plane, but it allows the focus to be on just a few characters, and family at that. Yes, it does feature Drake Hogestyn trying to emote (painful), but he wasn't the focus. The drama was spread across the passengers on the plane, but nobody got shortchanged. Each had their moments, especially Mary Beth Evans when Shawn Brady made his ultimate sacrifice. The family waiting back in Salem was good, and the direction wasn't dependent on special effects to get the point across.

Limping home in third place is "All My Children." This episode was all spectacle and no substance (except for Rebecca Budig, on too briefly). In the tornado, it seems like the whole town is affected. This didn't allow any one character to shine, or to reach out and touch the audience. It was all about spectacle, which left the whole thing a pretty, but empty, shell. It was a jumbled mess with no sense of purpose or direction. Plus, the acting was over the top and the writing was lackluster and choppy. That being said, if voters like big spectacle, they may vote for the "All My Children" disaster.


Slugfest at the Daytime Emmys: Christian LeBlanc vs. Anthony Geary

Photo: NATAS

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.

The comments to this entry are closed.


I agree that the scenes where Storm committed suicide and Lang's acting at the event were great. But, overall, I don't think this show deserves an emmy. Too many years have been devoted to Ridge Forrester and his wooden, painful, horrible acting. All this while a great actor such as Jack Wagner has to take a back seat to Moss's ego. Cannot stand to even look at the show anymore. It is gag worthy.

Overall,it was a fair article and I was especially impressed that Mary Beth Evan's work got a mention. She is a daytime jewel! The one thing that was not mentioned was that most of the actors on the Days scene selection were let go, and if Days did win, I sincerely doubt Corday will give any credit to these actors in his acceptance speech. As a matter of fact, he has changed the show enirely for the worst and lost families of Days viewers. He would be accepting an award for a show he went to great lengths to change, after this scene,thus, alienating the wishes of fans whose families, which include younger viewers, who have supported the show for years. I watched the show through different types of storylines,but this is by far the worst it has ever been. I no longer recoginze this show and do not watch!

That would be a great surprise if B&B won!

It would be a drastic change...saluting the rare(almost extinct)half-hour soap with a long-deserved statuette...which might prompt producers and networks to cut back or alter their existing shows or trot out new ones that would also be 30 mins. in length.

Normally there is only four nominees in the category. Going back 20 years there were only 3 times they had 5 or more.

Interesting that neither pundits made mention that there are only three nominees in this category this year ,down from the usual five.
I couldn't say if other shows Should have nominated but my guess is that fewer nominees will work in B&B's favor.

that having been said, B&B is deserving. Does anyone remember what it was like-cough, cough- when it first came on the air? Big improvement. Kudos to the stalwarts who have been able/or chose to stay with the show...

I have this bad feeling AMC is going to win, and if it doesn I am officially done with the Daytime Emmys!



In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Blogger

Pop & Hiss



In Case You Missed It...