The Envelope Logo

Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Oscar derby update: 'Hurt Locker' up, 'Amelia' down, 'Precious' holding on despite shocking snub

October 22, 2009 | 12:39 pm

Hurt Locker Amelia Precious Oscars

Here's the latest installment of our new weekly feature documenting latest twists and turns on the derby track, published every Thursday.

BEST PICTURE — "Precious: Based on the Novel 'Push' by Sapphire" suffered a shocking snub from the Gotham Awards when the indie film group issued its nominees. Does that mean it's hurt in the top Oscar races? No, according to the experts pooled by Gold Derby — read their reax here.

However, the Gotham Awards nominations did help to boost the Oscar hopes of its best-picture nominee "The Hurt Locker," which is getting a full-throttle academy campaign. The other top three Gotham nominees are not so Oscar lucky: "Amreeka," "Big Fan" and "The Maid."

BEST ACTRESS — Are Hilary Swank's new Oscar hopes may be crashing just like Amelia Earhart's plane? Early Oscar expectations soared high for the two-time nominee who's never lost ("Boys Don't Cry," "Million Dollar Baby"). Swank stars as a heroic figure in an epic biopic — usually that's a free ticket to Oscar heaven. And she managed to get some good early notices from the Hollywood Reporter and The Envelope's own Pete Hammond, but "Amelia" got scathing reviews from the Associated Press, Entertainment Weekly. Variety harrumphed, "To say that 'Amelia' never gets off the ground would be an understatement; it barely makes it out of the hangar." Still, many reviewers do still single out Swank's performance as a plus, like Roger Ebert, who calls it "sound" while she "uncannily embodies" the pioneering aviator. Is that enough to help her take off in the actress race if the film can't land in the best-pic category?

Meantime, the Oscar prospects of Helen Mirren are brightening in the best-actress derby. After viewing a recent screening of "The Last Station," Nathaniel Rogers of TheFilmExperience calls her shot at a nom "golden" as reward for her sensitive portrayal of the long-suffering wife of Russian novelist Leo Tolstoy. All Oscarologists know how much voters love to reward roles of long-suffering wives (Reese Witherspoon in "Walk the Line," Jennifer Connelly in "A Beautiful Mind," Marcia Gay Harden in "Pollock" plus gads more in both lead and supporting).

BEST SUPPORTING ACTORPeter Sarsgaard's Oscar odds just increased now that he's officially decided to opt for the supporting race. That news was broken Wednesday by Scott Feinberg (And The Winner Is …). Sarsgaard could've easily gone lead. He's not only got the most screen time among male stars of "An Education" (competing with Alfred Molina as Carey Mulligan's grumpy, skinflint papa), but he's the target of Mulligan's romantic yearning. Thus he's the emotional heart of the film — or at least he's got a lock on Mulligan's character's heart. Sarsgaard's role is rather lightweight, though, because it's mostly reactive to Mulligan's fawning and goo-goo-ing. He twinkles a lot. You don't get nominated for best actor of the year for best twinkling, but anybody can a ride into the supporting race if the film's got major Oscar mojo — even if they're undeserving, like Mark Wahlberg in "The Departed."

Photos: Summit Entertainment, Fox Searchlight, Lionsgate

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.

The comments to this entry are closed.


Swank is definitely out of the race, she does not show depth as an actress, always the same role.

This solidifies Meryl's win for Julie & Julia. She has a new poignant movie again- It's Complicated. With these 2 strong performances, the Academy will be a disappointing body if they will not give it to Meryl Streep this year. Every critic loved Streep's performance in J & J! Her performance is even bigger than the film last summer! So, let me get the reason why she cannot win this year? None! Meryl Streep for Best Actress!

The beginning of Amelia 20-30 min. so boring. Look like no one on tune to play...

Mark Wahlberg won Best Supporting Actor from the National Society of Film Critics, so how is it that he was "undeserving" of his Oscar nomination?

I don't think we can say things are getting 'snubbed' when they don't even get nominated for the first awards. Festivals are one thing, award shows another.

Tom O'Neill: Are Hilary Swank's new Oscar hopes may be crashing just like Amelia Earhart's plane?
That's very wrong to make light of such a tragic accident. Show some sympathy dude.

Oh, come on! Mark Wahlberg was completely deserving of his nomination in The Departed.

Or like Dan Akroyd in Driving Miss Daisy!

It's too soon (this year at least) to see anything like a frontrunner; the Gotham awards mean nothing to the best picture race, but I am now willing to think Hurt Locker could actually make history and win best picture.

Why? It would be by a huge margin the least-seen best picture winner ever during its theatrical run (some winners had fewer viewers at the time of the awards because they were late-year road show films not yet in general release), so that alone should disqualify it in members' minds.

But with the absence at this point of a real alternative, the chance that it might sweep the major critics' groups, and, ironically the new ranking of best picture nominees (meant to find a more mainstream, consensus choice) could really make this the winner, maybe only with best director (which I suspect Bigelow will win).



In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Blogger

Pop & Hiss



In Case You Missed It...