Gold Derby

The inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Ooops — strike '2012' off your Oscars best-picture list

November 11, 2009 |  7:53 am

Since part of an Oscar pundit's job is to jump off cliffs, bravely and spectacularly, we salute New York Post film critic Lou Lumenick for daring to forecast a best-picture nomination for "2012," 2012 movie Roland Emmerch news the upcoming apocalypse thriller from Roland Emmerich, director of "The Day After Tomorrow," "Godzilla" and "Independence Day." One of the chief reasons the academy expanded its best-picture list to 10 nominees from five was to include big popcorn pix that used to get nommed in the good ole days ("The Towering Inferno," "Jaws") but now are slighted. Unfortunately, alas, it looks like poor Lou will go splat against the Oscar rocks, according to Variety's gloomy review of "2012."

The trade paper predicts the doomsday thriller will strike lots of ticket gold: "This simultaneously spectacular and risible concoction looks likely to trigger a worldwide B.O. tsunami for Sony." But don't expect much academy gold: "On any level other than as sheer visual sensation, '2012' is a joke, for the simple reason that it has no point of view; the film offers no philosophical, metaphysical, intellectual and certainly no religious perspective on the cataclysm, just the physical frenzy of it all."

But, hey, "2012" does possess an "eye-popping display of movie pyrotechnics," says Variety. So it's not really the end of the Oscar world for the flick. Maybe it can still find salvation is some tech categories like sound editing and viz effects, saving Lumenick a bit on Oscar night too.


Busy week for Clint Eastwood; 'Twilight' dominates People's Choice noms; identity crisis for 'A Single Man'; can 'District 9' land in top 10?

Oscars to arrive late at the 'Precious' party?

Gold Derby nuggets: Pundits predict top races at Globes and Oscars | Pete Hammond: 'Brothers' has Oscars pedigree | 'Mad Men' recap and forecast

Quiz: What roles were nominated for both a Razzie and an Oscar?

Oscars quiz: Which movies won for writing, directing and acting, but failed to win best picture?

'Precious' star Gabby Sidibe sneaked in and was watching us!

Gold Derby nuggets: 'August: Osage County' vies for West End kudos | Dave Karger: 'Amazing achievement' of 'Precious' | 'Avatar' is half billion dollar baby

Gold Derby nuggets: 'Precious' shatters box office record; Taylor Swift soars on 'SNL'; still mad for 'Mad Men'

Oscars rewind: 'Slumdog Millionaire' tied for most European Film Awards nominations

Oscars predix for best pix from 16 experts

Oscars predix for best pix: Now the real experts pipe in – our forum moderators

Oscars predix: Who's ahead in the best actress derby?

Oscars predix: Who's ahead in the best actor derby?

'Missing Lynx' key to expanding animated feature Oscar race

Oscars voter: Michael Jackson's 'This Is It' will be nominated for best picture

'Precious' star Gabby Sidibe: 'It's so scary to think about' the Oscars!

Oscars derby update: 'Precious' finally breaks out, 'Crazy Heart' ambushes best actor race

Photo: Columbia Pictures

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.