Gold Derby nuggets: 'Brothers' enters Oscars race | Sasha Stone on sci-fi odds at Oscars | Lighter side of 'Serious Man' Michael Stuhlbarg
• Steve Pond reports that Lionsgate is mounting an ambitious Oscar campaign for Jim Sheridan's "Brothers" including "a best-actor push for star Tobey Maguire, who plays a soldier presumed
missing in Afghanistan until he returns home to his wife (Natalie
Portman) and younger brother (Jake Gyllenhaal)." Says Steve, "a full slate of screenings begins next week, with Academy-geared
television spots to follow. Lionsgate’s
awards website now promotes the film in a wide range of categories
including best picture, best director, best actor, supporting actor and
actress, screenplay, and song for U2’s 'Winter.'" THE ODDS
• Dave Karger thinks the just-opened " 'Fantastic Mr. Fox' stands a great chance of competing against the likes of 'Pixar' and 'Ponyo' " in the animated feature race. And Dave says that though "Petey's Song" -- Jarvis Cocker’s countrified ode -- "may not be the most beautiful track in competition this year the music branch often goes for the non-traditional choices." ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY
• Sasha Stone takes a closer look at the Oscars hopes of "Avatar," "District 9" and "Star Trek." Says Sasha, "Both 'District 9' and 'Star Trek' triumphed at the box office. Both films
were considered fairly lightweight yet wholly enjoyable. When you
think about honoring Best Picture of the Year, shouldn’t you also
consider successful films that were well reviewed and greatly loved by
the public? Yes, you should. Will they? Hard to say, what with the
whole Sci-Fi prejudice going in." As for "Avatar," Sasha thinks it, "is not just Sci-Fi but it probably counts as fantasy, too -- that’s a
double whammy against it right off the bat." She then enumerates four factors that could help one, two or even all three of these films land in Oscars top 10. AWARDS DAILY
• S.T. Vanairsdale pays tribute to Gordon Willis, who will receive an honorary Oscar at Saturday's inaugural Governors Awards, calling him, "the best cinematographer America ever produced." Vanairsdale says, "If he’d only shot the 'Godfather' trilogy, 'Manhattan,' 'Zelig' and 'All the President’s Men' (let alone 'Pennies From Heaven,' 'Interiors,' 'Klute' and 'Broadway Danny Rose') he’d have at least earned consideration among the greats like Gregg Toland and Billy Bitzer and his Oscar-winning contemporaries Conrad Hall and Haskell Wexler." MOVIELINE
• Anne Thompson sat down for a compelling interview with "A Serious Man" star Michael Stuhlbarg in which he, "talks about how he came to be cast in the period dramedy, working with
the Coen brothers, and how he is handling his serious good fortune." As Anne notes, "The fall release is likely to earn kudos with critics’ groups at year’s
end and could be a factor with the Oscars as well." And she wonders, "Will the Academy
actors recognize this theater star, or is he too unknown? Well, he has
now arrived. Next up: a major HBO series, Martin Scorsese’s 'Boardwalk Empire.' " THOMPSON ON HOLLYWOOD
Photo credits from top: "Brothers" poster (Lionsgate); "Star Trek" poster (Paramount); "A Serious Man" poster (Focus Features)
RELATED POSTS
Gold Derby nuggets: 411 on 'Nine' | Two perspectives on 'Avatar' | Four toons top 50 Oscars snubs
Inside track on the Oscars' best picture and best director races
Hmmm ... Can 'Inglourious Basterds' pull off an upset at the Oscars?
CMAs and ACMs are country cousins
Taylor Swift sweeps CMAs and makes history
20 animated films join a crowded Oscars derby (welcome, Alvin!)
CMAs to showcase top nominees including Brad Paisley and Taylor Swift
Ooops — strike '2012' off your Oscars best-picture list
Oscars to arrive late at the 'Precious' party?
'Precious' star Gabby Sidibe sneaked in and was watching us!
Oscars rewind: 'Slumdog Millionaire' tied for most European Film Awards nominations
Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.




"Brothers" all the way ... Jim Sheridan's best work since "In America" and really Tobey, Natalie, and Jake's best acting yet.
Posted by: Haddi | December 11, 2009 at 10:52 AM
I think "Brothers" is going to do really well in the oscar race. In my opinion, this review best explains why: “It was one of the most relevant films I've seen in a long time. It made the reality of the psychological horrors of war very real in a no nonsense way! This film by all means should be a sleeper hit with Oscar nods for Tobey Maguire, Jake Gyllanhaal and Natalie Portman who by the way was stunningly sexy and beautiful while delivering a convincing performance! Sam Shepard was Oscar caliber great as well. I totally loved this film and I haven't said about a movie in a long time.”
I think that social relevance is a huge factor in the film's success. There aren't alot of wartime films that can resonate with the general audience as well as "Brothers" seems to be doing.
Posted by: Anonymous | December 10, 2009 at 04:16 PM
I think 'Brothers' is a great Oscar runner this year.. good cast and director...
Posted by: gucci | November 19, 2009 at 02:55 PM
I wonder why Sasha thinks Avatar has elements of fantasy to it.
Interesting.
My particular 'fantasy' is to see well made sci-fi and fantasies become as legiit as serious dramas for Oscars.
Posted by: babypook | November 13, 2009 at 06:28 PM