Gold Derby

The inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Oscars are biggest winner of Emmys

March 10, 2010 |  9:25 am

The Oscars ceremony is the most honored television program in the history of the Emmys. Over the years, the annual celebration of the best in movies has racked up 46 wins out of 195 nominations from the television academy. That puts it nine Emmys ahead of "Frasier," with no end to the winning streak in sight. Indeed, even though this year's Oscars disappointed the TV critics, it should still fare well in many of the technical categories.

82nd Annual Academy Awards Oscars Emmy Awards Emmys In recent times, the Oscars show has averaged nine Emmy bids per year in various technical categories as well as noms for the host and the program itself. Last year, the Emmys did away with the individual performance in a variety special category -- a race Steve Martin lost in 2001 for his first hosting gig -- but Hugh Jackman was included in the program nomination. However, that maiden effort by Bill Condon and Laurence Mark lost the special class award to the opening ceremony of the 2008 Beijing Olympics. It did win four of its 10 nominations -- choreography, editing, song, and sound mixing.

Two years ago Gil Cates produced his 14th Oscars and, while the show sagged in the ratings, it did earn nine Emmy noms, winning for art direction and direction of a variety, music or comedy program. Jon Stewart earned an individual nom for his second time hosting, but lost to Don Rickles ("Mr. Warmth"). And the program -- shunted off to a special class category created just for awards shows -- lost to the Tony Awards.

Three years ago Laura Ziskin returned for her second try as producer of the awards show, having helmed the 2002 telecast hosted by Whoopi Goldberg. That 2002 ceremony went one for eight at the Emmys, winning only for choreographer Debra Brown (a feat Debbie Allen never managed even with her "Schindler's List" ballet). And the 2006 Oscars won two of nine noms -- art and music direction. Host Ellen DeGeneres lost the individual race to Tony Bennett ("An American Classic").

For the first 25 years that the Oscars were telecast, the shows earned little in the way of Emmys simply because the TV kudos didn't have categories to accommodate them. The first two Oscar telecasts, in 1953 and 1954, were huge ratings hits, but the first Emmy nomination came only with the third telecast, in 1955. The show competed in the category of best special event or news program. The NBC telecast -- hosted by Bob Hope in L.A. and Thelma Ritter in NYC -- as well as the World Series, the Rose Bowl and even the Emmys, lost to the CBS coverage of the A-bomb tests. That Oscar night is remembered as much for who lost (Judy Garland in "A Star Is Born") as for what won ("On the Waterfront" with eight statuettes).

Until the early 1970s, the Emmys had a melange of categories and the Oscars did not seem to fit into any of them. It made a comeback with the 1971 ceremony ("The French Connection" was the big winner, with five Oscars), earning two technical nods and winning for lighting. Then only another nine nominations over the next decade, with one win -- Jack Haley for producing the 51st ceremony in 1978 ("The Deer Hunter" won five Oscars). However, with the addition of many more categories in the early 1980s, the Oscars started hauling home Emmys and has never stopped since.


Complete list of Oscar winners

Gold Derby nuggets: Banned 'Hurt Locker' producer's Oscars speech | Stone & Hammond on 'Avatar' loss | Alec Baldwin on Oscars gig

How did 'The Hurt Locker' defy the odds at the Oscars?

Oscars ratings highest in five years

Oscar winners were predicted by guild awards

'The Hurt Locker' wins six Oscars, including history maker for director Kathryn Bigelow

This Oscars show was not a winner

Poll: What did you think of the Oscars telecast?

Photo credits: Emmy Award (ATAS); Academy Award (AMPAS)

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom