The Envelope Logo

Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

« Previous Post | Gold Derby Home | Next Post »

Beware: 'American Idiot' can pull off an upset at Tony Awards

June 11, 2010 |  9:02 am

More and more I hear rumblings of the possibility that "American Idiot" can pull off an upset for best musical at the Tonys over "Memphis" and "Fela!," the two presumed front-runners. (See breakdown of pundits' predictions here.) Lots of voters are confessing that they've checked off their ballots for it.

American Idiot Titanic Tonys Tony Awards-7

"Idiot" was believed to be the early Tonys front-runner, up until two glitches occurred. First, it didn't get nominated for best director (Michael Mayer). Just like at the Oscars, that's a nomination that usually must line up. Secondly, "Memphis" won the precursor prizes bestowed by the Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle Awards.

But those prizes aren't really crucial forecasters. Examples: the Drama Desk Awards recently picked "The Drowsy Chaperone" and "Wicked" over Tony champs "Jersey Boys" and "Avenue Q." Curiously, "Wicked" was considered to be the front-runner at the Tonys too — even though it wasn't nominated for best director. However, "Avenue Q" pulled off a jaw-dropper. (Undeservedly, I think — but that's another matter.)

There's one example in recent years of a show winning best musical without its helmer being nominated. It was "Titanic," which pulled off a surprise win in 1997.

Most pundits are currently betting on "Memphis" because it's a "book musical" with a traditional format of story, dialogue and songs. Voters are a conservative bunch — they usually like that. Also, those kinds of tuners usually tour well and, as every Tony pundit knows, that's important. Producers comprise the largest bloc of voters, and they want their best-musical champs to be winners at the box offices in St. Louis, Atlanta and Salt Lake City.

"Fela!" doesn't fit those bills, but still several of our Tony gurus are betting on it to prevail anyway. It's got the most nominations and a noble focus, telling the heroic story of Nigerian composer and activist Fela Anikulapo Kuti.

But "America Idiot" is really the best musical. It got the best reviews and whips up the most enthusiasm among attendees. It's got some drawbacks, sure — like little plot and dialogue — but it's the coolest, hippest contender.

Remember, the Tonys have a schizophrenic voting system. A small committee decides the nominees. Winners are chosen by more than 700 Broadway folks. Often the two groups disagree.

Photos: "American Idiot" (St. James Theatre), "Titanitc" (Lunt-Fontanne Theatre)

Get Gold Derby on Twitter. Join the Gold Derby Group at Facebook. Become friends with Tom O'Neil on Facebook. Get Gold Derby RSS feed via Facebook. RSS Feedburner. RSS Atom.

The comments to this entry are closed.


I thought that Green Day would win but then stupid shit "Memphis" won. I was so pissed, when they announced Memphis, I turned the fucking TV off and went upstairs to listen to my Green Day. Can you believe what a rip-off that was, how could American Idiot not win Best Musical? The Oscars to me is lame anyway, Green Day and the cast of AI can do so much better without those losers. Fuck em.

Having seen both "American Idiot" and "Fela!" within the last month, and being absolutely nutso crazy about both of them, I'd have to go with "Fela!" AI is wonderful, but to me its wonderfulness is largely due to the source material -- and to the fact that if you can get past the eyeliner and the breakthrough album named after feces, Billie Joe Armstrong is a damn good songwriter. But "Fela!" isn't just great, it's absolutely, astoundingly, transcendant. The most magical 2-1/2 hours I've ever spent in a theatre.

It's too rockin'/punkish for the stodgy Theatre Wing panel...but at least they're getting a little bolder with past choices like In The Heights, Rock of Ages, Xanadu (no matter how cheesey that was), Jersey Boys, Passing Strange, etc. ....musicals are hard to come by, so the Tonys will take whatever they can get...

Though I would agree with you Tom on American Idiot's has more of a drawback than merely no Best Director nomination. It doesn't have a book or a score nomination. Sure it wasn't eligable for Best Score, but going 0-3 on those big categories basically eliminates it. Also, since when as a musical won Best Musical with only 3 nominations? Also, American Idiot doesn't even have an acting nomination! No musical--at least in the nomination-era--has won Best Musical without AT LEAST a Best Director, Best Book, Best Score, or an acting nominations. Titanic: The Musical was at least nominated for and won Best Book and Score.

St. Jimmy Rules!!!!!!

One more drawback: It doesn't appeal to Broadway theatre goers.... No one survives if they don't sell tickets.



In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Blogger

Pop & Hiss



In Case You Missed It...