The Envelope Logo

Gold Derby

Tom O'Neil has the inside track on Oscars, Emmys, Grammys and all the award shows.

Category: Susan Lucci

Which 'Dancing With the Stars' judge deserves an Emmy?

September 24, 2008 |  5:30 pm

With this week's return of "Dancing With the Stars," the focus has been on colorful contestants like Cloris Leachman and Jeffrey Ross.

However, the judges have been the true winners on this contest show, considering how well they've coped with such crazy antics as Cloris Leachman putting her leg in front of Bruno Tonioli's face and her derriere down in Carrie Ann Inaba's lap?

Don't they deserve to be considered for their own Emmy? After all, the hosts of reality shows just got their own award. Why not judges?


Yes, says ATAS Chairman John Shaffner, they should be honored. Last weekend he confirmed to reporters that the Emmys will soon create an award for judges on reality TV shows like "Dancing With the Stars," "American Idol" and "Top Chef," but not for contestants!

"We don't want to turn into 'Survivor'!" Shaffner roared to Nelson Branco of TV Guide Canada.

So now let's check in and see what the medium's harshest judges — TV critics — think of how the judges performed this week on "Dancing With the Stars."

People's TV Watch lauded the male judges for their gallant reactions to  overtures from octogenarian contestant Cloris Leachman: "Ms. Leachman used her best acting skills to charm the judges. Her leggy display for Bruno Tonioli had him affectionately nickname her 'Battleship Geriatrica.' And the usually buttoned-up Len Goodman playfully told her, 'I always wanted to be a toy boy. This could be my big chance!' after Leachman gave the judge an eyeful of cleavage."

Yet E! Online reported they returned to form with their comments about other performances. Regarding Maurice Greene: "'Why did you do the 'Free Willy' step?' Len Goodman  wondered. 'What's that all about? I don't want all that nonsense!' And about Kim Kardashian, Bruno said, 'More wasted assets than Freddie and Fanny!" trying to provoke Kim into bringing that sexiness to the surface.'"

Sarah Rogers of our own Show Tracker gives kudos to Carrie Ann Inaba for suggesting Susan Lucci pack on a few pounds — "I thought [she] nailed it when she said that Susan looked a bit too frail out there" — and for letting Leachman sit in her lap.

Who do you think is most deserving of an Emmy nomination?


Meet the new Susan Lucci: Will Emmy's biggest loser Bill Maher ever win?

July 17, 2008 |  7:39 am

Bill Maher is already Emmy's biggest loser with 19 nominations and zero wins (Susan Lucci won with nomination No. 19). Today he got a chance to add to that losing record with two more producing nods for "Real Time With Bill Maher" (making its fourth bid for outstanding variety, music or comedy series ) and "Bill Maher: The Decider" (up for outstanding variety, music or comedy special).


Bill Maher's Emmy snubs date back to a 1995 nod for "Politically Incorrect" as outstanding variety, music or comedy series. ("The Tonight Show With Jay Leno" won that year for the first and perhaps last time.) Maher's ABC show brought him 11 nominations in total -- producing (eight), writing (two) and hosting (one). His current HBO series had earned him seven nods before today -– producing (three), writing (three) and hosting (one). In addition, he has a producing nod for his 2006 HBO special "Bill Maher: I'm Swiss." (That one lost to the opening ceremony of the Winter Olympics, no less.)

As Maher's losses are mostly for producing and writing, Angela Lansbury's record of 18 losses as a performer remains safe for some time. But more than likely, Maher will add to his losing ways this year. "Real Time" is up against "The Daily Show With Jon Stewart" (won the last five races in a row) and "Late Show With David Letterman" (won the previous five in a row), as well as "Saturday Night Live" (last won in 1993) and two-time nominee "The Colbert Report."

Maher's special is competing against a hodgepodge, including sentimental favorite "George Carlin: It’s Bad For Ya!" The late comedian never won an Emmy despite five nominations. Also in the mix are never-nominated Don Rickles, who picked up performing and producing nods for "Mr. Warmth: The Don Rickles Project," and Kathy Griffin, who celebrates the headlines she made for her Emmy win last year in "Kathy Griffin: Straight to Hell." Rounding out the mix are "The Kennedy Center Honors" (which last won this category in 1994) and "James Taylor: One Man Band (Great Performances)."




In Case You Missed It...

Stay Connected:

About the Blogger

Pop & Hiss



In Case You Missed It...